Sage Hobbit movie advice for PJ?

[gorthaur_cruel]

No, because Arwen was in Lothlorien at the time.

My bad. I forgot about that. Well, anyway, I wouldn't mind that much twisting of the story by PJ, compared to his corrupted Faramir, an eyeball Sauron, and ghostbuster armies.

It depends. If it is aimed at children like the book was, then a love interest isn't all that important. But if it's made out to be a huge story, then why would it hurt to give Bard a love interest? He ends up having a son, so why not include his future wife?

Well, all right. It slipped my mind that he had a son(stupid of me, I know). I suppose a bit of love could be put in, if only to satisfy the non-purists.