Dunedain policy vis-a-vis hobbits: wise or flawed?

[yavanna II]

Originally Posted by Child of the 7th Age

But Yavanna, if he saw the tough and brave side of Hobbits, why did he still feel that the only way to keep them safe was to isolate them totally from Men? It just seems like more of the same old isolationist thinking.

ya know what? I don't know!
Maybe he was scared history's gonna reapeat itself....
gee that's only my assumption.........