Gollum and Valinor...

[Dûrbelethwen]

Originally Posted by Nirvana II

i think so, because maybe if he hadnt been destroyed with the Ring Gollum would have dissapeared, leaving Smeagol, the good personality, alive. Or maybe Smeagol would have died anyway.

I am not sure if Smeagol is necessarily a good personality. In a book by Andy Serkis about his experinces during the making of Lord of the Rings he said in the last movie the writers wrote that the Gollom side was "less dangerous becuase of his passion, lust and agression were true hot-blooded emotions" and the Smeagol side was "cold, calculating, passive-aggressive phychopath who play-acted being the victim to get his own way." Since it was done in the reshoots that was when they were trying to get closer to the book.