How did Gandalf regain his staff? - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Araréiel · 07-08-2004, 08:43 PM

That, m'dear, is the power of a filmmaker's ability to add one is as he pleases!

How did Sam suddenly have a pony on part of the trail when he didn't leave with one?

really, in the film, just errors that were later corrected when, in fact, to leave them out would have made more sense. Such as Bill the Pony-only a scene or two made no sense, though we all know where he got Bill.

As for the staff, it fleets me right now. Maybe he managed to somehow steal it back? It doesn't seem that Elrond could could just make one. Oh! I know!

Accio Magic Staff! (If you don't get it, I'll sit here and smile smuggly like an idiot!)

07-08-2004, 08:43 PM	#3
Araréiel Registered User Join Date: Jun 2004 Posts: 92	That, m'dear, is the power of a filmmaker's ability to add one is as he pleases! How did Sam suddenly have a pony on part of the trail when he didn't leave with one? really, in the film, just errors that were later corrected when, in fact, to leave them out would have made more sense. Such as Bill the Pony-only a scene or two made no sense, though we all know where he got Bill. As for the staff, it fleets me right now. Maybe he managed to somehow steal it back? It doesn't seem that Elrond could could just make one. Oh! I know! Accio Magic Staff! (If you don't get it, I'll sit here and smile smuggly like an idiot!)