Reputations

[Imladris]

Meep! Let me explain myself.

My last sentence:

just find it silly to look for good Old Discussion when good new ones are around you.

was going back towards Evisse's statements that

nd when you're engrossed in a wonderful post that only a handful of people participate in, whom you'd like to award, it's rather hard to stop in the middle of it and search for old discussions to spread more reputation.

Granted, I chose very poor words but do let me redeem myself. Old threads are not bad. However, I think that going back to old discussions just to be able to rate a current favourite member (which is the impression I received from Evisse's post) is just...silly.

So, HI....I do not think that you giving rep to people who posted on Old Threads is bad. However, as you yourself said,

What makes you reluctant to praise the value of both?

was the gist of what I was saying...