Is all the "magic" gone? - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Vanya · 04-22-2004, 05:48 AM

One of members of the other, Serbian forum that I visit, has this experience:
She didn' read the book befor FOTR and TTT, she was delighted, overwhelmed with films. But, then she did read the book, and did so twice, before ROTK. She said that she was very disappointed by it, that it was full of holes.... but she saw it several times after ffew month pause. The impression was totally different then. She loved it!
I already said that for me, knowledge of the legends, history and great characters of old days, makes the magic of Lotr( book and film). What actor doesn' say, I understand. What the history of some place is (such as Amon Sul or Argonath, for example), that felowshipp passes by, I know and understand it.

04-22-2004, 05:48 AM	#11
Vanya Animated Skeleton Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: Belgrade Posts: 43	A fan's experience One of members of the other, Serbian forum that I visit, has this experience: She didn' read the book befor FOTR and TTT, she was delighted, overwhelmed with films. But, then she did read the book, and did so twice, before ROTK. She said that she was very disappointed by it, that it was full of holes.... but she saw it several times after ffew month pause. The impression was totally different then. She loved it! I already said that for me, knowledge of the legends, history and great characters of old days, makes the magic of Lotr( book and film). What actor doesn' say, I understand. What the history of some place is (such as Amon Sul or Argonath, for example), that felowshipp passes by, I know and understand it.