The Greatest Elf of Middle-earth?

[Afrodal Fenyar]

What did Tolkieen know, anyway?

Tolkien didn't know how to complete his book before his death. If you're speaking of JRR. So isn't there a possibility that he would have changed this too if he would've lived long enough?

Everybody in Tolkien's books is the greatest or the mightiest or the best in something. Anyways, it could be that Tolkien thought that it looks cool if he says that Luthien was the greatest.

So I still think of Fëanor as the greatest. I think that some things shouldn't be listed as facts.