If you could have.....

[Gorwingel]

Can I say that I wouldn't have really wanted to play a part... but actually I would have most wanted to take part in the behind the scenes action, more specifically the design of the costumes. The books are so descriptive, and give so many great details about the characters. That creating costumes that would perfectly fit them would be a dream job

A dream job that I would die for

But, hey, I wouldn't have to design them... I would have just sewed, or taken part in the fabric selection... I would have even just passed out the coffee.

But alas... I was much too young at the time, to take any part in any of this

[Fingolfin II]

I'd like to play Aragorn (not just 'cos of Arwen!) or Imrahil, because I don't think he was in the movie.

[Elianna]

Imrahil, because I don't think he was in the movie

I did see the silver swan on a blue field at Aragorn's coronation: from Aragorn's pov, to the right, behind Éowyn and Faramir. I was so happy when I saw it. I think Pete does it on purpose, makes the movies with some huge departures from the book so when we see something that should've been there all along, we're thrilled.

I think I really would've liked being Random Elf Chic #2 (if I couldn't be Éowyn): she's the one behind Arwen's left shoulder when the Fellowship is leaving Rivendell. See, then I'd get to meet most every main actor/actress person and be on the Rivendell set! Then I could look around New Zealand and go home, and not be stuck there 15 months.

[dkhyrosha]

As long as I was an elf, I would be happy. Legolas would be hard (concidering I'm a girl) but I could be an extra elf (under all that armor, I don't think anyone could tell I wasn't a boy)

but I wouldn't want to die either

[The Saucepan Man]

... but I could be an extra elf (under all that armor, I don't think anyone could tell I wasn't a boy)

Indeed, it might be a positive advantage given the "Chorus Line" which turned up at Helm's Deep.