Evil things - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

drigel · 03-18-2004, 01:51 PM

watch those grades Nirvanna lol .. although this medium is a lot healthier than my slacking tool of choice back in the college days... burp

freewill: reading the books it seems very black and white - once a maia turns evil it stays evil. But i wonder if (during this non-copreal state) if that spirit has the freewill to choose to be trapped by Morgoth. Trapped connotes to me an unwillingness.....

so... my orc hypothesis is falling short in my mind concerning the trapping of spirits. Too many to take into account. When i read the threads, it seems the conclusion on the orc creation thing is relying mainly on a physiological platform of breeding. right?

It does seem to me that if Morgoth could trap a Maia's soul, he could easily trap an elf's soul as well.... no?

03-18-2004, 01:51 PM	#30
drigel Ghost Prince of Cardolan Join Date: Dec 2002 Location: commonplace city Posts: 518	watch those grades Nirvanna lol .. although this medium is a lot healthier than my slacking tool of choice back in the college days... burp freewill: reading the books it seems very black and white - once a maia turns evil it stays evil. But i wonder if (during this non-copreal state) if that spirit has the freewill to choose to be trapped by Morgoth. Trapped connotes to me an unwillingness..... so... my orc hypothesis is falling short in my mind concerning the trapping of spirits. Too many to take into account. When i read the threads, it seems the conclusion on the orc creation thing is relying mainly on a physiological platform of breeding. right? It does seem to me that if Morgoth could trap a Maia's soul, he could easily trap an elf's soul as well.... no?