Sauron in Numenor - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Tharlionglin · 03-16-2004, 04:10 PM

I disagree, if yo ucan show me where it says the ring came to Numenor I would appreciate it but this is the real reason for the thread. It does however say that he takes up the ring in Barad Dur again with no mention of it while he was in Numenor, and no mention of Sauron using it Numenor. Don't you think that he would have if he could?

To think that his spirit carried away the ring is a bit far fetched, if he could 'carry' the ring while in spirit form why would he have left it on the battlefield for Isildur, why wouldn't he swoop into the Anduin and claim it. It's obvious that he went to great lengths to have the ring brought to him, by his agents of darkness.

03-16-2004, 04:10 PM	#9
Tharlionglin Pile O'Bones Join Date: Mar 2004 Posts: 12	I disagree, if yo ucan show me where it says the ring came to Numenor I would appreciate it but this is the real reason for the thread. It does however say that he takes up the ring in Barad Dur again with no mention of it while he was in Numenor, and no mention of Sauron using it Numenor. Don't you think that he would have if he could? To think that his spirit carried away the ring is a bit far fetched, if he could 'carry' the ring while in spirit form why would he have left it on the battlefield for Isildur, why wouldn't he swoop into the Anduin and claim it. It's obvious that he went to great lengths to have the ring brought to him, by his agents of darkness.