Branded in the Tower of Cirith Ungol? - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

12-31-2003, 02:54 PM

hmm I never actually noticed that at all I was just so relieved that Frodo wasn't totally naked. um. but what I did wonder about was which one if Shagrat and which one is Gorbag? when they come down to pick up Frodo wrapped in his cacoon dealy, in the book Shagrat is the one who says "this fellow aint dead" which led me to believe that the pointy green one was Shagrat. but then in the tower, the big black orc calls the green one "morgul scum" which made me think he was Gorbag. does anyone have proof?

12-31-2003, 02:54 PM	#21
SuperMaiario Guest Posts: n/a	hmm I never actually noticed that at all I was just so relieved that Frodo wasn't totally naked. um. but what I did wonder about was which one if Shagrat and which one is Gorbag? when they come down to pick up Frodo wrapped in his cacoon dealy, in the book Shagrat is the one who says "this fellow aint dead" which led me to believe that the pointy green one was Shagrat. but then in the tower, the big black orc calls the green one "morgul scum" which made me think he was Gorbag. does anyone have proof?