In Defense of PJ

[Diamond18]

<BLOCKQUOTE>quote:<HR> He obviously didn't read the books. <HR></BLOCKQUOTE><P>Well, of course they read the books. They're a couple of the better known Tolkien artists, as a matter of fact. Why Greg's quote is strange is this:<P> <P>This is another Hildebrandt picture, of Éowyn slaying the Witch-King. If that ain't main action, I don't know what is.<P>Anyway, why all the Glorfindel talk...again? Eru, don't we have entire threads devoted to that subject already? I have no idea why that is such a sticking point for some people. Arwen's scenes were exciting, she stood up to the Nazgul, and that whole chase was cool. The only thing we're missing is yet <I>*another*</I> male character. And I don't hear anyone lamenting the loss of Fatty Bolger night and day. Sheesh.<P>We were supposed to be dwelling on the positive aspect of PJ's film, anyway, instead of re-hashing old complaints.