Eowyn or Arwen?

[Manardariel]

Ok, Haldir those are all good points, but not reasons. <BR>1) Who said Arwen <I>needs</I> to got to Valinor. What she "needs" what she wants is in Middle- Earth: Love, Aragorn, their future. I think,even if Arwen would have gone to Valinor, she wouldn´t have forgotten Aragorn, nor would she have been happy there. Amd we´ve seen it before that Human/Elf can Work.... Luthien/Beren, Idril/Tuor were all happy with what they chose.<P>2)Um, well, if he would take over Rohan, he´d be in DEEP TROBLE. He couldn´t have done that. Look, Rohan was a gift, you can´t just take it back. Besides, he wouldn´t have survived the War of the Ring without Rohan- Eomer, Theoden etc. It´s not exactly nice to "reward" the dudes tht help you get your thrown by taking their country away, is it?<P>3) WAY NOT!!