arwen - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

03-16-2002, 03:38 PM

Have to agree with most of you. Arwen would have been just fine if Aragorn had realized she was coming and hailed her. And if she'd been smart enough just to keep going past the ford. Give her some intelligence and dignity, for heaven's sake, and without detracting from other characters! It is possible to be sympathetic and caring without overdramatizing things. Had Arwen been understated a little, I think she would have come off much better. The handling of her character was rather thoughtless. And the quote from Ebert was spot on--these movies are supposed to be about hobbits! It wouldn't have ruined the movie to focus more on them!<P>I hope Arwen doesn't show up in Rohan. If so, they'll be ruining one of the only female characters in LOTR. Eowyn should not have to compete with Arwen for warrior-princess honors.

03-16-2002, 03:38 PM	#39
lamarquise Guest Posts: n/a	Have to agree with most of you. Arwen would have been just fine if Aragorn had realized she was coming and hailed her. And if she'd been smart enough just to keep going past the ford. Give her some intelligence and dignity, for heaven's sake, and without detracting from other characters! It is possible to be sympathetic and caring without overdramatizing things. Had Arwen been understated a little, I think she would have come off much better. The handling of her character was rather thoughtless. And the quote from Ebert was spot on--these movies are supposed to be about hobbits! It wouldn't have ruined the movie to focus more on them!<P>I hope Arwen doesn't show up in Rohan. If so, they'll be ruining one of the only female characters in LOTR. Eowyn should not have to compete with Arwen for warrior-princess honors.