arwen - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

the_master_of_puppets · 03-05-2002, 12:28 PM

i kind of understand the scene in rivendell, but i just found it a bit...erm, cheesey? just how she seemed so sure of herself and i felt it made aragorn look weak. i thought it was inaproptiote 4 her to put a knife to his neck and go 'whats this a ranger caught off his guard?'- i mean she obviously would have knowen what was going on and the last thing u'd want to do was pretend to knife the guy when frodos lifes in jepardy!<P>i agree liv did well with a perhaps not-4-the-better changed character...i just kind of found her alot more annoying than in the books. and i still cant see her crying at frodo: maybe getting frustrated, worried, frightended 4 him: but crying? it just seemed so out of place after the whole heroine act. and yes her actions with aragorn were almost taking away our attentions from frodo...<P>maybe her role will improve in the next 2 films...lol

03-05-2002, 12:28 PM	#11
the_master_of_puppets Haunting Spirit Join Date: Jan 2002 Location: scotland Posts: 77	i kind of understand the scene in rivendell, but i just found it a bit...erm, cheesey? just how she seemed so sure of herself and i felt it made aragorn look weak. i thought it was inaproptiote 4 her to put a knife to his neck and go 'whats this a ranger caught off his guard?'- i mean she obviously would have knowen what was going on and the last thing u'd want to do was pretend to knife the guy when frodos lifes in jepardy!<P>i agree liv did well with a perhaps not-4-the-better changed character...i just kind of found her alot more annoying than in the books. and i still cant see her crying at frodo: maybe getting frustrated, worried, frightended 4 him: but crying? it just seemed so out of place after the whole heroine act. and yes her actions with aragorn were almost taking away our attentions from frodo...<P>maybe her role will improve in the next 2 films...lol