Accuracy of the Movies - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

nPiLL · 03-05-2003, 08:39 PM

Iarawain, what do you mean just for you npill? Please tell me what that is supposed to mean. <P>About them dropping this thread, i dont see why they would because it is not a bad thread. In the FAQ it says only things that can be discussed. I think this is definatly something that can be discussed.<P>Back to the LotR. I felt the was very good because if you think about it, if they had included everything in the book i think it would become to boring for non-LotR fans. Many of my friends who wouldnt even think of reading a LotR book liked the movie.<P>I also think the main reason they did not include every scene was because they needed to make a profit off of the movie. If they included everything the non-LotR fans would not be interested and would not go and see it. Therefore, they tried to include as much as they good while trying to keep it both interesting for the non-LotR fans and the LotR fans.<P>Thats just what i thought about it.

03-05-2003, 08:39 PM	#8
nPiLL Haunting Spirit Join Date: Feb 2003 Location: An aching yet comfortable crevice in Moria. Posts: 59	Iarawain, what do you mean just for you npill? Please tell me what that is supposed to mean. <P>About them dropping this thread, i dont see why they would because it is not a bad thread. In the FAQ it says only things that can be discussed. I think this is definatly something that can be discussed.<P>Back to the LotR. I felt the was very good because if you think about it, if they had included everything in the book i think it would become to boring for non-LotR fans. Many of my friends who wouldnt even think of reading a LotR book liked the movie.<P>I also think the main reason they did not include every scene was because they needed to make a profit off of the movie. If they included everything the non-LotR fans would not be interested and would not go and see it. Therefore, they tried to include as much as they good while trying to keep it both interesting for the non-LotR fans and the LotR fans.<P>Thats just what i thought about it.