*TTT - Haldir (Craig Parker)* - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Nianna Telmnar · 12-29-2002, 08:30 PM

I agree it would have been a huge tragedy. (and most likely led to riots of Tolken fans in theatres) but the question is would it have been better for the movie's flow? I mean, if your going to kill off and elf, why not one we would have a real attachment to as opposed to one who gets 5min screentime? (please note i have yet to see the extended dvd of FOTR)<BR>*note: i am not supporting nor discrediting the appearance and killing of elves at helms deep, just making a point*<P>Oh, and I really like that Haldir is a little more rounder in the face and has brown eyes. The other's were starting to look like clones.

12-29-2002, 08:30 PM	#11
Nianna Telmnar Haunting Spirit Join Date: Dec 2002 Location: somewhere between here and there Posts: 68	I agree it would have been a huge tragedy. (and most likely led to riots of Tolken fans in theatres) but the question is would it have been better for the movie's flow? I mean, if your going to kill off and elf, why not one we would have a real attachment to as opposed to one who gets 5min screentime? (please note i have yet to see the extended dvd of FOTR)<BR>note: i am not supporting nor discrediting the appearance and killing of elves at helms deep, just making a point<P>Oh, and I really like that Haldir is a little more rounder in the face and has brown eyes. The other's were starting to look like clones. __________________ "Don't Panic."