The Greatest

[Orald]

Very cute Mithadan, but don't you think the question is too broad to be so specific. I would have at least included several people in the elves humans and dwarves category.

I think Feanor and Galadriel were about equal, but Feanor might have been just slightly greater. And as for Dwarves, unless it mentions Azhagal(I am fairly sure it doesn't) Then Durin the Deathless would be right up there at the top to me, and then maybe Azhagal and Telchar and a few others. And Men, to many different kinds of men to even start, I mean what about that Druedain in UT...

Of course we all have our own ideas of what makes someone great and with the few exceptions of where Tolkien explicitely states, but I am sure everyone already understands this and this was a wasted post