Book vs. Movie characters

[Lord of Angmar]

Failivrin, when you just use vague descriptions like someone was "good", "stupid" or you "didn't like" someone, we don't get the impression of why you feel this way.

gimli: odd accent. pretty good. bad comic relief

I loved the accent, but I did not enjoy his overused part as the comic relief in the Two Towers, especially not at Helm's Deep, where the tension had truly reached grandiose proportions before Legolas made the "box" crack about Gimli's height.

Why the ragging on Merry and Pippin? I thought Dominic and Billy were great choices (especially Billy, Scottish accent and all).