Feanor - Overrated?

[the phantom]

and none BUT the creator ( Eru/ Illuvatar ) should have the right to command them so in where they should go and where should they live. Illuvatar instructed the Valar that Elves and Men is to inhabit Middle earth and dwell therin. if you bring a race (Noldor ) from the place where they was created to dwell by their creator (Middle-Earth). and the reason you give was to protect them from the evil of their kindred ( Melkor ). then you dont secure them when one of them (Finwe) was brutally killed nor capture the one who cause it. You basically negated the reason for them even being in Valinor in the first place.

Jedi shoots... he scores!! [img]smilies/biggrin.gif[/img]

he didnt have to kill the Teleri. but he did it in his mad desperation to follow Morgoth to middle earth

Actually, I think he might've had to. Read the thread below to find out why I have this radical belief. Even if you don't agree, it's a great thread from beginning to end. http://forum.barrowdowns.com/cgi-bin...=1&t=003412&p=

(and welcome to the Downs, Jedi, you'll fit in fine)