If the ringbearer died

[Mhoram]

Speculation is fine, so long as it is clearly marked as such. Through carelessness you guys convinced Sleeping Beauty that it was fact.

I had forgotten that Eru had created Hobbits for the purpose of bearing the ring...I need to go read my history again.

We could talk about this specific instance until we're blue in the face, but what really matters is people need to learn to be more careful about such things. It's irresponsible to say things as if they are fact when there is nothing to support it; and it's weakmindedness to accept such statements without consideration.

Am I being mean and insulting? Yes, I am. Think people.