Anyone for a good debate? - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Iarwain · 11-06-2002, 09:41 PM

Forgot to respond to cudae. This is what i have to say. Don't take this personally or anything, but I am absolutely SICK of people commenting on why Tolkien would not have written another sequel. This was not supposed to be a main part of the question. I have even removed all metion of whether or not Tolkien would have written the dagor dagorath (sorry I messed up on the last post). I understand that Tolkien probably would never have written the story of the End and published it. The point of the debate was that I could see if anyone thought otherwise and find out why. When I wrote the opening post, I intended each person to give their opinions on all questions stated. Unfortunately, I phrased it in a way in which it was widely misunderstood. The interpreted question caught on, and I have yet only gotten one person to answer the question I truly intended to ask, and that is Manwe.

-my boots are fading

11-06-2002, 09:41 PM	#16
Iarwain Pugnaciously Primordial Paradox Join Date: Sep 2002 Location: Birnham Wood Posts: 800	Forgot to respond to cudae. This is what i have to say. Don't take this personally or anything, but I am absolutely SICK of people commenting on why Tolkien would not have written another sequel. This was not supposed to be a main part of the question. I have even removed all metion of whether or not Tolkien would have written the dagor dagorath (sorry I messed up on the last post). I understand that Tolkien probably would never have written the story of the End and published it. The point of the debate was that I could see if anyone thought otherwise and find out why. When I wrote the opening post, I intended each person to give their opinions on all questions stated. Unfortunately, I phrased it in a way in which it was widely misunderstood. The interpreted question caught on, and I have yet only gotten one person to answer the question I truly intended to ask, and that is Manwe. -my boots are fading __________________ "And what are oaths but words we say to God?"