WW LXXXIX: The Terror of Tol Fuin

[Thinlómien]

Innocent
Nogrod - well I don't really like it how he, Legate and I seem to have a sort of "buddy club" atm, but he honestly seems very innocent to me at this point. Like I said yesterDay, he makes sense enough to make an innocent impression while not making sense enough to give an innocent impression (I have noticed that guilty Nogrod often makes too much sense. Meaning of course that he makes more the kind of arguments that are similar to other villagers' arguments and thus often more like my own thinking.)
Sally - declaration of innocence argument + toDay I've actually finally seen some more proof for thinking she's innocent: she seems to make solidly sense the way Sallywolves do less than Sallyinnocents. She gives me an honest feel.

Innocentish
Eomer - I keep flip-flopping on him and he's difficult to read etc etc but right now he seems pretty ok.
Legate - seems sensible and open in an innocent way (haha I think you probably can't be open in a wolvish way though! ) mostly. I still haven't ruled out him being in process of pulling of the effortless legatish wolf-trick though.

No idea
Bom Tombadillo - to be blunt, I hope he either appears or stops voting and gets modfired, now he's too enigmatic.
G55 - to be honest, she's pretty much under my radar. I have to agree with Eomer that it's possible Lottie was her fellow, but I'm not sure how likely it is. For some reason, my brain seems to be on some off mode whenever reading her posts.
Greenie - under my radar. I like her points, but her votes have been a tad too easy to my taste (might of course just be that she always has to vote early but still). I would need to see something a bit more drastic from her one way or the other to judge her better, but unfortunately she's not a very drastic player.

Suspicious
Nilp - like I said, refraining from analysing frustration. All I have to say to that is: I hope you keep playing, whatever your role, because I enjoy playing with you and it happens more seldom than I'd prefer. I'm sorry if I said something offensive, that was not my intention. However, my suspicion based on the points I mentioned remains (although I have to admit Nilp's initial answer to my Lottie-Mith-Nilp theory made me a tiny bit less uspicious of him) - I think refraining suspicion would be a poor way to apologise even though I am sorry if I'm (part of) the reason why you consider leaving the game.
Mithalwen - see above for apologies and suspicion. My clear top suspect at the moment for possibly trying to save Lottie and having too much wolvish insights plus maybe for sounding like a cornered wolf.


edit: xed with all three posts