WW LXXXIX: The Terror of Tol Fuin

[Galadriel55]

I'll have to vote a bit early toDay (about 1.5 hour from now), and considering that during the last hour you get the most writing, I'll have to vote without that information (which may come in useful). Unless something happens while I'm still here to change my opinion, I'll be voting one of those in my Orange category.

Edit: xed with Nilp. *goes to read his post very carefully *

[Nogrod]

A few notes from reading the thread.

It does look like Kit really was building mountains out of molehills with her cases against Sally and Bom. And later it seems she is actually saying that Bom is suspicious for real! That makes me suspect her a lot more.

On the other front, Lottie made both of her cases of not knowing Kit was playing before there were suspicions of the two being in cahoots (if there ever were ones), and basically before anyone had suspected herself the first time. Some had questioned Kit at that point though.

The way a known wolf Lottie tries to suspect G55 makes me think G55 more innocent than not.

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

Off to bed now so here are my thoughts for posterity.

G55 and Sally top two suspects. Both act suspiciously and defensively; G55 perhaps more so, independently, but Sally is incriminated by some of this behaviour. They are also the two top posters in the thread: it sometimes seems as though they're trying to drown out opposing voices by sheer volume of words.

Kitanna interests me but I lean toward giving her the benefit of the doubt. I certainly want to see the twain named above hanging from the gallows before Kit.

In the spirit of simplicity the Loslote voters are fine and probably innocent. Legate and Nogrod post well and sensibly. Lommy seems innocent to me, as does Greenie actually. Must be a family thing.

Everyone else worries me immensely - especially that tom-fool Nilpaurion. Trust him not, I say!

[Galadriel55]

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

G55 and Sally top two suspects. Both act suspiciously and defensively; G55 perhaps more so, independently, but Sally is incriminated by some of this behaviour. They are also the two top posters in the thread: it sometimes seems as though they're trying to drown out opposing voices by sheer volume of words.

I never knew that the post count could be used as an accusation!

Originally Posted by Eomer

Everyone else worries me immensely - especially that tom-fool Nilpaurion. Trust him not, I say!

Agreed. I still can't classify him on my suspocion list (slippery him!), but I don't trust him. Neither do I trust you. >.<

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

When I mentioned not trusting Nilp:

Originally Posted by Galadriel55

Agreed. I still can't classify him on my suspocion list (slippery him!), but I don't trust him. Neither do I trust you. >.<

It's a thought. Dear cousin Nilp is becoming a problem!

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

Legate, I am quite simply Kath to your Mormegil: in every game you suspect me! You need to realise that it's the way I post, and has nothing to do with my role.