Tol-in-Gaurhoth L: Battle of the Fandoms

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Um... you do realize there's only one wolf now, don't you? You've already been corrected by Mac once, yet you still reason:

What's the matter with you?

I don't see the problem... sorry.

That quote concerns the ending of Day3 when Wolfisaloser2008 was lynched - and she had a mate then - that mate is indeed among us still as otherwise we would have won this already.

So were you Nerwen a wolf you would have been very annoyed looking at Sally going down (your last mate that is as I said there) and the way you try to bring forwards Fëa's "revelation" twice kind of looks like saying it cautiously that we should perhaps look at Fëa at the last minutes rather than lynch Sally.

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Finally, as for these 20-20 hindsight points you make about me having suspected innocents... um... so have you

I do agree with you that suspecting or even voting innocents is no "proof" of anyone's lupinity. Of course not, as we all do it all the time. But if McCaber has been unbeliavably right all the time you have been very-very-wrong all the time managing to basically suspect or turn the discussion to ordos all the time without getting it right at all. Now I don't say it's impossible one gets things totally wrong - it's happened to me as well and I think to everyone - but it's not usual after four Days... So I thought it was worth noticing among other possible reasons to suspect you.

Talking about luxuries:

Nogrod, I find your lack of faith disturbing....

Sadly a werewolf-game isn't the place where you'd be happy to make a leap of faith as your first act.