Werewolf XLIV: In the House of Tom Bombadil

[Rikae]

Originally Posted by Volo

Of course I don't claim myself to be a Wolf. Is there any possible reason for doing so? Sure it is possible, I have just as big a chance of becoming a Wolf as any. Then again, I might say that everything is possible, and only possible, but inevitable. But that would be already physics and not WW..

Except that, presumably, you actually know your own role...

[Rikae]

Actually, though, I suppose I could see Volo saying what he said innocently (from the perspective of the rest of the village). Bah.

[Rikae]

So, Mac, what are you?

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by Rikae

So, Mac, what are you?

You expect me to tell you and spoil the fun?

[Volo]

Originally Posted by Macalaure

You expect me to tell you and spoil the fun?

A Wolf, otherwise you would have been nicer.

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by Volo

A Wolf, otherwise you would have been nicer.

I'm usually especially nice when I'm a wolf.

Usually...

[Rikae]

Originally Posted by Macalaure

I'm usually especially nice when I'm a wolf.

Usually...

Next week, you can sleep in the back yard. There's a nice, soft snowbank out there. Germans make good candy, so maybe they make good popsicles, too?

[Rikae]

Originally Posted by Macalaure

You expect me to tell you and spoil the fun?

I hate you.

Expect to be punished for this...

[Volo]

Originally Posted by Rikae

Except that, presumably, you actually know your own role...

Yes, but from your perspective it is still just as possible, unless you're a Wolf. *shrug*

Making a slip in a situation like that would need something even I don't posess.

1) One could have misread the three names, not noticing his own name.

2) One might have tried to say that, of course, the combination is possible and the only way to prove it otherwise to everyone is for one of the players to die.

3) It could have been an intentional revelation, but why so vague and why did the person then deny it as soon as he was asked.

4) It could have been a slip. The person automatically connected his own name to a Wolf. This would need the person to go out of himself and look at the game from a perspective of a mod, or something. Not only! That would also mean that the two other players (Durelin and Mac) are Wolves, because otherwise it can't be a slip because the player doesn't know the roles of the other players.

I must say that we encountered a rather amusing half-a-paradox.

[Volo]

I love this game.

[Meneltarmacil]

Yes, Volo, I see what you mean. In the absence of a Seer, every little comment can be jumped on for maximum value due to us having no solid leads.

EDIT: X-posted with Mac.

[Nerwen]

I believe Volo's was a killing vote.

Mac, seems you just died. Are you a wolf?

I fear not– that last post of Volo's looks awfully gloating.

[Rikae]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

I believe Volo's was a killing vote.

Mac, seems you just died. Are you a wolf?

I fear not– that last post of Volo's looks awfully gloating.

I believe Mac has 5 votes and Volo one, with four players left to vote... so if they're all around,.... "it's possible"... Volo could be lynched.

[Rikae]

No, that's right -- only three haven't voted, I think.

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Mac, seems you just died. Are you a wolf?

Don't you know that?

[Volo]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

I fear not– that last post of Volo's looks awfully gloating.

Oh but that it is! I just managed to prove that I'm right and it couldn't have been an unintential slip.

[Volo]

On Menel. I don't think he's a Wolf, because Mac is obviously one. Menel pretty much suspected only Mac most of the time, a bit too bold, if you ask me. Then again, he might have gotten lessons from Nogrod on how to lynch a partner.

[A Little Green]

*phew*

Huh, I'm back. This is nerve-wrecking.

Volo is very confusing. What is this Nerwen-obsession of his? I can't follow his logic on people's attitude about her at all (the more you suspect Nerwen the more innocent you look). I would like an explanation from him before I conclude on whether it's wolvish or merely odd.

Lommy's frequent repetition of her playing style bothers me, but otherwise she looks genuine. "I only behave like this when I'm innocent, therefore I can't be a wolf" is not what I'd call a valid argument. It's ok if you say it once or so, but Lommy has been repeating it more than is necessary (I'm not sure whether that argument is ever necessary).

I'm now more convinced than ever that Mac is a wolf. Therefore,

++Mac

Sorry to have been so uncontributing toDay. I promise to be more active toMorrow.


EDIT: x-ed with everything on this page

[Rikae]

Originally Posted by A Little Green

I'm now more convinced than ever that Mac is a wolf. Therefore,

++Mac

Oh, that's priceless.

[A Little Green]

Hee hee I was right!!!

Just tell me one thing, Mac... Was the quote I spotted really a slip?

[Volo]

Oh no! Lily! You missed to mention your 100th post!! Congratulations!

Now,

[Rikae]

Just want to say this in case I don't survive --
take a good look at Dury tomorrow, folks.

[Nogrod]

Never try to play a game with three people sharing one computer...

But as it actually looks pretty clear now, then...

++ Macalaure

But that done I must say I'm not at all too happy with this whole thing. There were too many easy bandwaggonings toDay and I must agree with Volo that I do not like it. With the unanimous decision the fellows have just slipped in to join.

And to make things harder I must say that Nerwen's vote for Volo looks pretty suspicious as a kind of self-confident wolf-move disassociating herself from the wagon on a fellow... and thence claiming individual reasoning outside the madness when we toMorrow start searching for the ones joining the wagon with bad or non-believable reasons...

That just because I see at the moment Volo more as weird than a wolf. I mean I don't get half of the points he makes and his "confessions" look just too attention-calling that no wolf would do that... or then would... OMG.

EDIT: X'd from Menel onwards...