T-I-G LVI: Panic at the Prancing Pony - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Macalaure · 01-24-2009, 12:00 PM

Lily -> Gollum - the first vote, looks neither innocent nor suspicious
Lommy -> Aganzir - flip-floppy, but that doesn't mean much. The vote alone is neither suspicious nor innocent either
Gollum -> Brinn
Aganzir -> Lari - why does she vote randomly? She did have suspicions and opinions, yet she discarded them
Legate -> Mac - first real vote of the day
Shasta -> Lommy
Nogrod -> Gollum - it's not that he criticises random votes, that's to be encouraged, but that his choice is limited to it, that's unnecessary
Menel -> Mac - maybe there's a bit of a revenge involved, but his reasons alone are awful
Rune -> Brinn - he is so over the top about her, that he's probably innocent
Fea -> Brinn - giving somebody a third vote for paranoia's sake? suspicious
Mirandir -> Lommy - looks fine to me
Beregond -> Mac - picks up what everybody else is talking about without mentioning it before. Bandwaggonish vote and reason, something a newbie wraith might do.
Durelin -> Lommy - another could be either vote
Sally -> Mac - not as awful as Menel and Beregond, but still
Lari -> Durelin - throws her vote away in order to prevent a double lynch: suspicious
Rikae -> Lommy - the first vote intended to save me, no reason to suspect
Nerwen -> Gollum - if she's a wraith and one of the other candidates is, too, she would have found an easier way to save that one. If she's a wraith and the other candidates are innocent, she could have chosen a player with a bigger name to get rid of. She must've known that her vote would make others follow and that a different vote would have discouraged them. It doesn't seem to fit, so it's probably an innocent vote. Interesting, though, that she does not mention Brinn in her vote post.
Mac -> Gollum
Brinn -> Gollum - had pretty much the same reasons as I did, plus she was annoyed with him
Rikae -> Gollum - she talked about voting him before but only did so after his death was more or less sealed, which is a bit strange

Suspicious vote: Aganzir, Fea
A bit suspicious vote: Nogrod, Menel, Beregond, Lari
Somewhere in the middle: Lily, Lommy, Durelin, Sally, Rikae
Less suspicious vote: Rune, Mirandir, Nerwen, Brinn
Innocent vote: Legate

Nogrod is trying to hide in the open, I see.

Fea, those were only the options that came to my mind, of course. I didn't say that there are no others. Even incomplete lists like these are helpful, though, I think, as long as people don't end up thinking that there are no other ways.

01-24-2009, 12:00 PM	#11
Macalaure Fading Fëanorion Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: into the flood again Posts: 2,911	Lily -> Gollum - the first vote, looks neither innocent nor suspicious Lommy -> Aganzir - flip-floppy, but that doesn't mean much. The vote alone is neither suspicious nor innocent either Gollum -> Brinn Aganzir -> Lari - why does she vote randomly? She did have suspicions and opinions, yet she discarded them Legate -> Mac - first real vote of the day Shasta -> Lommy Nogrod -> Gollum - it's not that he criticises random votes, that's to be encouraged, but that his choice is limited to it, that's unnecessary Menel -> Mac - maybe there's a bit of a revenge involved, but his reasons alone are awful Rune -> Brinn - he is so over the top about her, that he's probably innocent Fea -> Brinn - giving somebody a third vote for paranoia's sake? suspicious Mirandir -> Lommy - looks fine to me Beregond -> Mac - picks up what everybody else is talking about without mentioning it before. Bandwaggonish vote and reason, something a newbie wraith might do. Durelin -> Lommy - another could be either vote Sally -> Mac - not as awful as Menel and Beregond, but still Lari -> Durelin - throws her vote away in order to prevent a double lynch: suspicious Rikae -> Lommy - the first vote intended to save me, no reason to suspect Nerwen -> Gollum - if she's a wraith and one of the other candidates is, too, she would have found an easier way to save that one. If she's a wraith and the other candidates are innocent, she could have chosen a player with a bigger name to get rid of. She must've known that her vote would make others follow and that a different vote would have discouraged them. It doesn't seem to fit, so it's probably an innocent vote. Interesting, though, that she does not mention Brinn in her vote post. Mac -> Gollum Brinn -> Gollum - had pretty much the same reasons as I did, plus she was annoyed with him Rikae -> Gollum - she talked about voting him before but only did so after his death was more or less sealed, which is a bit strange Suspicious vote: Aganzir, Fea A bit suspicious vote: Nogrod, Menel, Beregond, Lari Somewhere in the middle: Lily, Lommy, Durelin, Sally, Rikae Less suspicious vote: Rune, Mirandir, Nerwen, Brinn Innocent vote: Legate Nogrod is trying to hide in the open, I see. Fea, those were only the options that came to my mind, of course. I didn't say that there are no others. Even incomplete lists like these are helpful, though, I think, as long as people don't end up thinking that there are no other ways.