Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Pitchwife
Everybody sing along with me:
Dead innocents don't know anyone's role,
Dead innocents don't know anyone's role etc.
Which is to say, even though they're free of evil intentions, our beloved quarantined may still be wrong and the baddies can hijack a vote for a non-wolf.
|
No, they don't, but they have read
Gal and
Huine's interactions on the QT thread and know what lead them to pick
Brinn yesterDay.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Kath
The first vote after the reveal was Lottie's, half an hour after sally's vote, and that was with 7 minutes to go, and by the look of it almost every vote from then cross posted. Out of all 9 actual voters there, no one took the plunge of pushing forward another candidate fast enough. Very likely there are wolves who didn't want to be the first onto an alternative bandwagon who were watching the insanity with glee. But looking at the lateness of Legate and Mac's votes, who we now know were innocent, means not immediately throwing out an alternative doesn't automatically equal wolf.
|
Yes, but
Legate for instance was quite convinced of
Sally's guilt.
Mac wasn't.
I'm getting more and more convinced it is not in the innocents' interests for everyone to leave their votes to the last minute. (Why do you think I've voted earlier than I had to 2 days in a row?) Dudes, let's learn from our mistakes and spread out the votes a little toDay, so we have time to discuss and react to each other's votes. Please.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Lottie
The other important thing to consider here is, Lommy is a very good player who is very good at arguing for her innocence. If anyone could get away with encouraging the village to quarantine a Hunter who was very likely to take an innocent with her, it would be Lommy. With five wolves, I could see them agreeing that someone should be playing loud and bold, and that Lommy was the best person to do it.
|
Awwww, this warms my heart a little! But to be honest, I am a crappy and unhappy liar irl and it often shows in werewolf too *points at signature*
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Lottie
I'm with Lalaith here - it was very hard to think and plan around Lommy arguing that we should just quarantine Sally yesterDay. There wasn't another voice arguing with you, so we all just ended up quietly doing our own things without coordinating at all, and a lot of that (from what I remember) was just not being able to coordinate over you.
|
Then the question you should ask is probably
why was there not another voice arguing with me? Why did everyone keep discussing
Sally? Like it's been said, she revealed 45min before the deadline. Not as much time as would be ideal, but certainly plenty. Did the discussion loop around
Sally because both innocents who wrongly suspected
Sally and wolves thought lynching
Sally was a good course of action? Then who was who?