I agree the list "
Pitchwife,
G55,
Macalaure" was a bait, but I don't recall much coming out of it. Furthermore, I can't see it looking as a seer dream by itself as they couldn't have had three dreams by this point and there's nothing to differentiate between the trio.
First "substantial" post #121: voices not particularly convinced suspicion of
Gal,
Pitch and
Mac. Again, no seer vibes.
Vaguely defends
Legate. I can kinda see the grounds for
Mac's paranoia based on #128 because Rikae seems to be operating with rather "how do I prove my suspicion of
Mac is correct?" rather than "is my suspicion of
Mac correct?" But it's still pretty far-fetched.
#138 laconically puts
Brinn in the spotlight (for saying "I'm still a bit wary of
G55 and
Pitchwife (less so of the former), however I don't want to get caught in a trap.") which... sounds like an innocent catching a suspicious whiff they later fixated on, but it could of course have been interpreted as a seer finally finding a legit reason for voicing suspicion for their wolfy dream.
#148 it continues:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Rikae
Anyway, right now my fake vote would go to:
++Brinniel
For immediately repeating 2 of 3 names from my list as suspicions, and then backtracking explicitly to avoid getting caught in a trap right after I explained to G55 that my post was intended as a wolf trap. That was ostensibly a reply to Mac saying the group was mostly innocent, but the coincidence is just too much for me to ignore.
I know, these are the kinds of things a wolf would definitely make sure not to do, right? Right. So much so, it could be used as cover. And an innocent doing them coincidentally? That feels like a bigger stretch to me.
|
Mac is sort of out of
Rikae's main suspects by now. He was really like a side note on
Rikae's suspicions. So why is he so fixated on that?
Rikae's real suspicions seemed to be divided between
Gal and
Brinn. And I don't think the
Brinn suspicion looks very seerish; on the contrary, it builds up based on the events on the game thread.
Thoughts?
Based on this, I'd say
Mac looks much worse than
Brinn. If
Brinn is a wolf, I very much doubt
Rikae looked the most seerish of all the villagers (remember there are four more wolves who could have had seerish accusations against them).
If
Brinn is innocent, then I think
Boro might look more innocent too (for his weird presumption that she's guilty, would a wolf think that way?) and
Lottie looks worse (as has been pointed out, she sounded like she knew
Brinn was innocent).
While
Mac's conviction of it looking like
Rikae-seer dreamt of him looks very paranoid wolfy. I'm unwilling to go very meta on this, but it all makes even more sense to me with
Rikae/
Mac being a RL couple and with them having been unhappy being on different sides in ww before. It's not a reason enough alone to incriminate
Mac, but I think wolf!
Mac would like to kill innocent!
Rikae early on even if they didn't look particularly gifted. Of course, there would probably have to be other reasons for picking
Rikae to convince his packmates it's the best choice.
Also? I think
Rikae's death makes
Legate look a little more innocent. He was the only one they consistently talked of as an innocent (including mild defense of him) and that alone might have been enough to ping the wolves' seer radar if neither
Brinn nor
Mac is a wolf.
I still would kinda like to lynch
Brinn because her role would shed light on others'
but I'm leaning towards lynching
Mac as the best option toDay.
edit: xed with Legate and Hui and no time to read or reply right now