Quote:
Originally Posted by Nerwen
Mmn– except that you list nine villagers at #194, made before your reveal. I can't be the only one to have noticed that.
|
But if you look at her list, she writes
2 ordos, not 3. You say you caught her in a lie, but I say it's only a mistake. You "feel" like you're a wolf that desperately wants to get rid of a dangerous gifted, and pulling at every word in her posts to try and find arguments for that.
Sally, you're not stupid. You've just made a mistake - a bad one, no question, but just a human mistake. I know what you mean, and I think you know what I mean too.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kitanna
True, but Sally, what if your target ends up being one of said roles?
|
It won't. She's a logical hunter.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Kit
You quoted Greenie, not me.
|
My bad. I was rushed, and I was arguing with both of you.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Kit
Today: The main thing I want to touch on now is the fact she has completely written off Nog as the cobbler. She does say he could be a wolf, but seems to dismiss this for the belief he's the cobbler. Based on her own belief that he is thus, she questioned me why I said Sally could be the cobbler and not him.
|
First of all, I explained my reasoning already in one of my first posts toDay, where I said that he could either be wolf, ordo, or cobbler, the third being the only likely option. Secondly, I didn't question you why you think
sally is the cobbler. I asked you what do you think
nog's role is if you say
sally is the cobbler.