Quote:
Originally Posted by The Squatter of Amon Rûdh
...pig-headed Morwen...
|
I hope you meant
big-headed Morwen...
Quote:
|
Another interesting point is that despite his many failures, Túrin remains a hero.
|
Heroes aren't necessarily successful. But they still may be heroes.
And that reminds me. At one point, I believe when Turin was ruling at Amon Rudh, Morgoth was afraid that he will overpower the curse. This might have been the most successful time in his life.
But it brings up a question: did Morgoth have faith in his own curses?
Quote:
|
Although by far the darkest of Tolkien's heroes, he never becomes as corrupt as does Fëanor; and ultimately he succeeds in his mother's ambition for him: he is never a slave.
|
He "fares free". Now that you mention that, I think that there is a deeper meaning behind those words.
I think we can equal Turin and Feanor in this sense: they are both, in a way, legendary. And I think that Feanor is more fey than corrupt - as is Turin.
I sometimes wonder why Turin calls himself Turambar in Brethil. Does he wish to defy his fate? Does he think that he rose above it? I used to think that this particular name choice was made on purpose by Tolkien to create the irony of "Master of Doom, by Doom mastered".