Commenting while reading...
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nerwen
Which is another thing– there's been a surprising amount of what looks like signalling. And yet, in this game, why bother?
|
Well I think it'd always be usufel for the evil side to know each other. After all, if they manage to identify each other, they can join forces. Which makes this:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nerwen
Actually– even though there's not much need for a cobbler to hint in this game– that post looks a lot like he's doing just that. "Bingo! Nice work, my wolfish mistress!"
|
a fair point and makes
Boro go quite high on my list of possible cobblers. (Alongside with
Phantom,
Glirdan,
Lottie and several others. I wish I had as many wolf suspects.)
Mmm, people seem to mean that
Boro being a cobbler hinting at me means I'm a wolf. Wrong. It only means he thought I'm a wolf, and if you suspect me based on that, you suspect me of being a wolf just because he does. Pretty fishy logic (or high trust in
Boro's skills of observance), I'd say.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nogrod
So speaking about an "ordo" means an ordinary innocent aka. having no role.
Speaking of an "innocent" means a non-wolf.
|
NO!!! (Okay I know I'm arguing with a dead person but this is something I feel rather passionately about.) I agree "innocent" doesn't equal "ordo" like some people seem to think, but "innocent" doesn't include cobbler who's not innocent because they're not on the innocent side!!!
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Fea
Edit: crossed with Glirdy... who seems to have spatula'ed himself from one side of the pan to the other. Which, in my brain, sends him from pan to fire... Ie: he didn't really help his cause.
|
Totally cracked up at this.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Lottie
TP's being a cobbler makes Lommy look better
|
Why?
I'm rather worried I have no more to comment. I'm somehow feeling a bit detached from everything, and I think it must have to do with the fact that we don't know the roles of the dead. I think
Nogrod was most likelily a cobbler, but if he was the seer that really sucks. However, his role doesn't matter to me that much, I think
tp seems rathe cobblerish in any case.
And
Fea's death... let's not make the same mistake and leave the evidence of her being picked unanalysed.
xed with all