Quote:
Originally Posted by Nogrod
That in turn would mean that there should have been a clear enough seer-hint with clear enough guilt shown for someone who actually is a wolf. Which would actually be Eonwë There would go my theory of him being Dionysos which I have to admit I rather like still - and actually (and hopefully) he was the false seer, so it is still possible I'm right with Eonwë. But that we shall not know until later.
|
See my post
here for why I don't think
Boro dreamed a wolf. (Although, note that this is all according to my logic, and
Boro, clearly, has his own.)
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nogrod
The other thing is, were the wolves killing him because of the seer hints? I mean now after the fact it's more or less easy to say "ahh, right youy are, he was hinting to be the seer!", but I must admit at least I missed them completely yesterDay.
|
Okay... I thought they were pretty much impossible to miss yesterDay; I thought he was probably bluffing, though.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nogrod
On another issue. I still think my theory about Eonwë is quite plausible, whatever you say. The rules say only: There is no remark on any loyalties he should or should not have and thus leaves it quite open for Dionysos to choose himself his loyalties (we don't know what Glirdan wrote in his role-PM to him of course).
Now knowing how so many people think that playing a wolf is the coolest thing one can do in Werewolf it's not that far-fetched to think someone being the cursed - and knowing it - would really desire for actually getting to be a wolf.
|
Well, some people do play it like that–
Agan did when she was a Cursed who knew her role, ages ago. An awfully risky tactic though. I'm not sure I'd try it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nogrod
Third one. It was not so much reasoning in any strong sense but a feeling that was based on few things. With Mac it was more or less not so much him suspecting Nerwen but Nerwen's attack on him that made me think they probably are not on the same side (cannot be proved and wolves can do that, to be sure)
|
I presume
this is what you're talking about? I happen to know it
isn't wolf-on-wolf, but even I can see how it could easily look that way. It's fairly cautious and lukewarm, whereas Mac's attack on me was a good deal more definite.
I'm not sure what I'm getting at here... maybe just that you seem to be interpreting everything in the exact opposite way to me.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nogrod
her excellent pick on Nerwen trying to influence the ideas of Zeus' alignments
|
Mind jogging my memory as to what my fiendish goal was at that point?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Eönwë
So, are you saying that as a wolf you'd rather kill the seer than leave one of your own to get killed so early on?
Because Boro basically voted for me for no reason, so obviously if the wolves killed him it would point straight to me. Wouldn't that be more than a little risky?
|
Don't be silly,
Steve. A dreamed wolf has to be written off anyway– and I think most packs would consider it worth the risk.
Ha, that's
such a dodgy argument! Maybe I should be worried about you after all...