Quote:
Originally Posted by Nogrod
Roa: Sorry, I just don't get your analysis on Boro...
Where are the deductions there from?
How are you making those points from Boro's posting? What kind of "theory of motivation" do you use there?
Boro is most suspicious of someone = points away from that person as one who'd kill him during the Night?
Boro suspected someone = that person would have killed him?
Boro "slightly" suspected someone = that person probably didn't go to kill him?
Boro considers voting for someone = maybe not enough to kill him?
Not only do I find this "analysis" odd but also a bit too purpose-oriented...
And how do you find me and Greenie being in cahoots, on the basis of what Boro said? How would his words be any authority on that, how would have his words related to anything asa he was a bear and knew nothing? Still you say your deductions are based "solely on this" ( = your analysis on what Boro said).
Are your werewolf -schemes getting better of your good sense and you were creating there a wannabe conspiracy-theory of three wolves and forgot that Boro was a Bear?
Or did I miss something?
|
Allow me to explain: I'm looking at it from the perspective of the wolves not knowing that
Boro was the bear. If they did figure it out, then discussing his death is rather pointless, but we have know way of knowing if they did.
I don't think a wolf would kill someone who blatantly found them to be the most suspicious, as it would quite obviously point to them. I
do think that a wolf might kill someone with the goal of making someone else look bad. That's why I initially thought
Greenie-wolf may have killed
Boromir to make you look bad. But then Boromir did a 180 on the whole thing, suspecting
Greenie and not you.
And then I remembered what
Greenie said, about a connection between you and me, and I thought about why she would say that when I just ignored you. And then it occurred to me that she may be trying to cover up her own tracks in doing just that. It really would be a perfect cover- one of you always suspects the other, anyways, so no one would find that out of the ordinary. And if one of you got lynched, the other would automatically look good. She fell into the easy vote of voting for you, and you built a suspicion of her and then backed down. It seems rather perfect wolf-on-wolf to me.
As for the rest, I tried to put myself in the position of the wolves, thinking on each person in perspective: a slight suspicion may not be worth killing over. A suspicion that wasn't exactly slight, but wasn't the strongest? Well, that has the potential to be dangerous and grown into
the strongest suspicion.
I may be over-thinking it.
Boro wasn't shy about discussing the bear, so it's possible the wolves picked him out. Or maybe the wolves just wanted to get rid of a strong player that could be a threat to them later. The point is that we don't know, so we have to continue to look at all the possibilities. This alone wouldn't be enough to lynch anyone, which is why I emphasized the "based solely on this" part.
Edit: Crossed with Pitch and Inzil.