[MLD-Grounds-Keeper-Willie]

Well the question is whether her immortality or love is more important. Obviously her love is more important than immortality. And is it really irrational to sacrifice anything at all for true love? Sometimes you have to sacrifice something important for love. This goes along with my point that Tolkien wanted to show; sometimes in order to gain something, you have to lose something. But I do not think it was irrational at all. I would have made the same decision, although it would be for a woman because I'm a man. Love is definately worth the sacrifice. To be lonely is one of the worst feelings in the world.