I'd agree with
davem. I think the formulation that the usurpation of power is pretty correct. But, however true you are,
davem, I think what you speak of would be just the "normal" corruption by power. That's what the people who made (or considered, cf. below) themselves the ultimate rulers would do, everyone putting the Middle-Earth into the shape of their own imagination, but that won't accord with Eru's plan and thus, be "evil". The Ring, I would presume, would break the last barriers of their conscience and so, even for people like Sam or Galadriel or Faramir or Gandalf, they will cease to care of the others and go after their own goals (even if the goals were to be seen as "good" by them). The moment of taking the Ring for your own is when it happens - that's why there's so much emphasise putting on it, that's why it's so important that Bilbo, Frodo, Sam... received (or came to, but "received", I think, is appropriate word here) it (and not took it by force), though later the former two declared the Ring as "their own and no one's". By taking the Ring for your own, you say "I have the RIGHT to have it and it is only mine, no one else has the right to relativise this" (the words "mine and no one else's" define it pretty well, but I want to make clear what I speak of). Simply said, Bilbo, you don't have the right on claiming the Ring, it's not yours. You cannot say "the Ring should do this and this and never anything else" - at any time, the Ring may pass to anyone else (like Frodo) and you cannot object it. That's the thing Melkor said about Arda:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Ainulindalë
When therefore Earth was yet young and full of flame Melkor coveted it, and he said to the other Valar: "This shall be my own kingdom; and I name it unto myself!"
|
The point is that no one can ultimately say this about anything. Even Aragorn, let's say, does not have any right to say that he is the King and it can be never changed. Like Treebeard said, "'never' is too long even for me." Remember that first, Melkor did not want everything to become Darkness: he wanted to claim the Light and to make everything his own. He turned to that "nihilism" when he realized that he cannot have everything ("mine - or no one's!"), that there is still the will of Eru above him, whatever he would do.
In connection with this, maybe there's just only one thing I'd think about, and that's that from what we know, I think there are hints that ultimately the Ring (because it has part of Sauron's power in it) could lead even Galadriel (or these folks we speak of) into doing things that would remind us of Mordor, meaning now the real, "physical" Mordor - destruction and darkness. I think if she retained her status for some time, she'd ultimately start to fade into these "evil" things we know. First, as I said above, she could realize that even as the ultimate ruler there is the will of Eru above her, and she could decide then between just two things: to bow down and obey (diminish, go into the West, remain Galadriel - and leave her Mega-Lórien behind), or to oppose even Eru - and if she went into the extreme as Morgoth did, she would come to the state that the only thing she could do will be destroying everything. "Okay, Eru, I see I cannot control some things against your will, so I will at least destroy them". And here we go. The same path.
Or second, thinking in less extreme ways, maybe something else could happen, because the Ring could come to work here. That's something
Raynor mentioned about the "higher evil forces that are uncontrollable"; when Galadriel would have reached the ultimate power in Middle-Earth, there will also be nothing else for her that she would consider "higher" than herself (at least to the point I mentioned above, when she would start to struggle against that what would oppose her), which means, she is the ultimate and despotic ruler, just as Melkor and Sauron at certain point of time thought they were. In this moment, in our Galadriel case, the Ring would come to work, because the person won't have any other things to hold to, and the Ring would probably convince her to "build Dark Towers and create Ringwraith". Why do I think so: Because there is a part of Sauron's personality in the Ring. It does not have anything to do with Galadriel's dreams or goals. But I think the personality of Sauron in the Ring would make her do things even she wouldn't like to do, and she would do them. Strange? I think not - just imagine it. "Hey, why could you not make a Nazgul from Elrond? You ask why would you do that? Well, why not? You are the ruler - you can do everything you want. No one can ban you from turning Elrond into a Nazgul. So prove it." It would take long, perhaps millenia, but I think even Galadriel could start to do things that would make her somewhat like the real Sauron, if she possessed the Ring - and ultimately, the Ring will possess her.