Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim
Could any Catholic (or Christian - not at all sure of the relevant differences) comment on the significance of Galdriel's desire for power? Is it not slightly evil?
|
Well, I'm Catholic. Galadriel's desire for power isn't neccesarily evil. She wanted to rule a realm at her own will without the tutelage of the Valar. She was after all brilliant in mind. In the LOTR she has a more Marian quality (virgin Mary) & exhibits qualities similar to that of Melian & Varda. She doesn't plan to become the next Dark Lord by desiring the ring. It merely gave her an oppurtunity to enhance & preserve her already existing power (Nenya). Her pride too was a key element of her desire for power but ultimately she passes the test. She wasn't evil, but I'd say she is a tester (if that makes any sense).