09-16-2022, 03:40 PM
|
#1
|
Dead Serious
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Perched on Thangorodrim's towers.
Posts: 3,337
|
**Spoiler Warning** Rings of Power S1E4 - "The Great Wave"
Another week... and am I the first Downer to watch it again? Dear me, how either I or the show have fallen if that's the case.
The stream-of-thought things I noted:
- ...still sounds like "Adan." That orks needs to work on his "r"s!
- Is Míriel having the Faramir dream? ... Seems so...
- Wait, I just heard the name "Míriel!"
- What--Pharazôn has a son? Are there two Pharazôns?
- Well, I like the populism angle of Pharazôn (however many there are) as leader of the King's Men.
- Did he say his name is "Kevin?"
- I'm not sure that it's intended for Míriel have more queenly presence than Galadriel, but she does--which I like on the former, but not so much on the latter.
- Isildur the dreamer doesn't make canonical sense--the one anecdote of we have of him in youth is as a DOER.
- "Dead brother!" Anárion is... dead? AND his older brother? Well, this doesn't bode well for the Line of Anárion, I must say.
- Okay, that time I heard the "r".
- Wait--"adar" = "father" = "do you know how the orks first came into being." It's the missing link! The archaeopteryx of Orks!
- Sirion or Ossir? I suppose both are verboten...
- Not a god yet has to be "this is Sauron"-bait.
- "Here to Orodruin"--I'm gonna say, "yup," this is the making of Mordor we're seeing.
- "Theo" is still a stupid name.
- The Southlands story still belongs to the horror genre, I see.
- If you tell me that Celebrimbor is inventing this recollection of Eärendil, I'd believe it...
- The whole "deception of Durin" story seems... I dunno, either like it made our intro to the Dwarves pointless or redundant or inconsistent or something...
- Okay, I like a secret knock!
- It's a bit a late to be finding mithril... but the whole timeline is pointless to nitpick in this show.
- Betcha that wee bit of mithril becomes an Elven ring or three.
- Why do the bars on Galadriel's prison look like a 21st century wrought-iron fence?
- A mortal Southron princeling should not be teaching the granddaughter of Finwë politics--never mind the granddaughter of Olwë or the student of Melian.
- Okay, Halbrand is a Mary Stu. It's okay. But he is.
- That the King of Númenor has declined is a very... Númenórean motif.
- Wait, is a that a palantír--it is! Why are six missing? I mean, it makes sense that they're in Númenor--and that's kind of under-developed by Tolkien: what were they doing in the 2nd Age? Did the House of Silmarien have them all? Were there others? How did Elendil end up with them all?
- Theo, I think you should really think of going back without that sack.
- Good timing, Arondir. But I still suspect you've saved a Nazgûl.
- This is very Boromir's death. Are we going to that well again?
- Saved by the Sun! Not a bad motif!
- Are we giving Elrond Daddy Issues™? I guess... that's not... terribly... inappropriate. Still.
- Durin and HIS dad have a very... Dwarven? thing going on.
- Well, this is a creepy bartender! An anti-Barliman?
- I like Míriel's look between without the leafy antlers.
- Making a public pronouncement indoors in a city that large seems like it's making an event rather exclusive...
- So, it seems we're going to get some Tar-Minastírian alliance PRE-Sauron... the timeline here is so muddled!
__________________
I prefer history, true or feigned.
|
|
|