Visit The *EVEN NEWER* Barrow-Downs Photo Page |
04-29-2009, 02:56 PM | #41 | |
Loremaster of Annúminas
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 2,317
|
Dior is a very interesting case, especially since it could be argued that Luthien was already mortal when she and Beren actually married. But it's plain that the Valar hadn't really thought things through when Earendil turned up! (Unfortunately Dior was only 36 when he was killed, so we have no idea whether he had the "youth of the Eldar" or not).
According to Manwe in QS (1937): Quote:
I do find it interesting that the choice was explicitly given to Earendil's sons, Elrond and Elros, and that that choice was extended to Elrond's children- but not to Elros'!
__________________
The entire plot of The Lord of the Rings could be said to turn on what Sauron didn’t know, and when he didn’t know it. |
|
04-29-2009, 09:03 PM | #42 |
Ghost Prince of Cardolan
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 1,033
|
And if the QS idea is held to be true, then Arwen, Elladan and Elrohir are automatically mortals to my mind... that is, if Elrond or Elros chooses immortality here he will yet have automatically mortal children with respect to death (as they will still have some measure of mortal blood).
My theory is that the Children of Elrond must at least be extended the choice in order to make Elrond's choice fair to begin with (and the same with Elros had he chosen an immortal fate). In this way, no person with mortal blood (in any measure) is automatically withheld from a mortal death -- release from the Circles of the World and time. And no children are automatically sundered from their parent if that parent chooses immortality. |
04-30-2009, 08:25 AM | #43 | |
Loremaster of Annúminas
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 2,317
|
Quote:
I think therefore that your 'revised rule' pretty well sums up what Tolkien came to believe as a result of the LR, modifying what had been a firm rule before he started it. Back to the Dioscuri: it's interesting that to the extent they are described, they do not "pass" as Elves: "And have you marked the brethren Elladan and Elrohir? Less somber is their gear than the others', and they are fair and gallant as Elven-lords; and that is not to be wondered at in the sons of Elrond of Rivendell." And then there is the passage from a draft of Appendix A, describing their role at the Field of Celebrant: "In the forefront of the charge they saw two great horsemen, clad in grey, unlike all the others, and the Orcs fled before them." I don't want to lean too heavily on a single adjective, but one could infer that if they were "great" even among the tall Northmen, that the brethren were quite large persons indeed, more "Mannish" than "Elvish" in build, if you will. By the way, if anyone cares, Arwen and her brothers were not half-elves, but 78.125-percent-elves: 18.75% Men (3/16) 17.1875% Noldor (11/64) 7.8125% Vanyar (5/64) 53.125% Teleri (17/32) 3.125% Maiar (1/32) Elrond himself was a nine-sixteenths-elf. (I didn't distinguish between Sindar and Teleri of Aman because of Celeborn's uncertain status)
__________________
The entire plot of The Lord of the Rings could be said to turn on what Sauron didn’t know, and when he didn’t know it. |
|
04-30-2009, 10:44 AM | #44 |
Pilgrim Soul
Join Date: May 2004
Location: watching the wonga-wonga birds circle...
Posts: 9,455
|
Ah but don't forget that Legolas was comparing them to a bunch of hairy Dunedain rangers dressed for the worst that the wild could throw at them, and with the noted height of their maternal grandparents they were unlikely to be short by the measure of the elves - however I expect the mannish blood may well have made them more strapping than the average elf... though this now leads me to envisage Arwen as a jolly-hockeysticks Betjemanesque heroine...
__________________
“But Finrod walks with Finarfin his father beneath the trees in Eldamar.”
Christopher Tolkien, Requiescat in pace Last edited by Mithalwen; 05-01-2009 at 09:37 AM. Reason: sp.. |
04-30-2009, 12:48 PM | #45 | |
Loremaster of Annúminas
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 2,317
|
Quote:
__________________
The entire plot of The Lord of the Rings could be said to turn on what Sauron didn’t know, and when he didn’t know it. |
|
04-30-2009, 01:53 PM | #46 | |
shadow of a doubt
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Back on the streets
Posts: 1,125
|
Quote:
The choice of Arwen, as an descendant of Eärendil, is of course to share the fate of mortal Men and leave the circles of the world, or to sail West with her father and remain bound to Arda until the end. When she gives her heart to Aragorn, she is taking the former path, which I think in practice means that when she comes face to face with Mandos sooner or later he will send her soul to where Men go (Heaven, I suppose), and not the Halls of Waiting. Within the context of the story, the idea of Arwen repenting of her choice and begging for admittance on a ship heading West, thus ie abandoning Aragorn, or just living on in Middle earth, perhaps joining Maglor in his wailing, is preposterous. We may speculate about many what ifs, but in the light of Tolkien's (in-book) idealised view of love and marriage, there were only two options for Arwen: to join Aragorn in life and death or to remain with her father and pass West. The technicalities of the choice and its consequences beyond this is speculative and in the end without import - well, apart from the continuation of this thread, which certainly has a value of its own. Edit: Jeez, the mental picture of Arwen the Warrior Princess is not a pretty one haha.
__________________
"You can always come back, but you can't come back all the way" ~ Bob Dylan Last edited by skip spence; 04-30-2009 at 01:58 PM. |
|
04-30-2009, 02:58 PM | #47 | |
Wight
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 120
|
Quote:
|
|
05-01-2009, 10:00 AM | #48 |
Pilgrim Soul
Join Date: May 2004
Location: watching the wonga-wonga birds circle...
Posts: 9,455
|
Oh William, you certainly picked that ball up and ran with it... taking the merely formidably athletic to the positively Wagnerian... which may be a valid source but scary.....After all, the standards of beauty in ME may have been rather more Rubenesque than usally supposed. Not that I have a problem with that in itself only with the extrapolated mental image of Luthien dancing for Beren looking like one of the corp de ballet in Fantasia *snork*.
__________________
“But Finrod walks with Finarfin his father beneath the trees in Eldamar.”
Christopher Tolkien, Requiescat in pace Last edited by Mithalwen; 05-01-2009 at 10:03 AM. |
05-01-2009, 10:07 AM | #49 | |
Loremaster of Annúminas
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 2,317
|
Quote:
On Rubenesque heroines- I doubt it. One of T's favorite adjectives for good-lookin' wimmen, besides "fair," is "slender:" Goldberry, Galadriel, Eowyn and p'raps others all get the label. And Luthien is "lissome", which can be taken as the antonym of "hippo."
__________________
The entire plot of The Lord of the Rings could be said to turn on what Sauron didn’t know, and when he didn’t know it. |
|
05-01-2009, 10:36 AM | #50 |
Pilgrim Soul
Join Date: May 2004
Location: watching the wonga-wonga birds circle...
Posts: 9,455
|
Oh I know ... and of course Luthien is so linked with Edith who was very far from being even betjemanesque...
but some how my mind's eye is refusing to expect the overwhelming textual and contextual evidence ... my bad...
__________________
“But Finrod walks with Finarfin his father beneath the trees in Eldamar.”
Christopher Tolkien, Requiescat in pace |
05-03-2009, 06:59 AM | #51 | |
Wight
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 120
|
Quote:
I suspect that not all Elves necessarily have a noble and gallant bearing - I liken Elladan and Elrohir to Elves like Gil-Galad and Glorfindel. Elves who are handy with a sword and a spear and also born to rule. |
|
05-05-2009, 08:22 PM | #52 |
Mighty Quill
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Walking off to look for America
Posts: 2,230
|
Didn't Elros already choose his childrens' fate anyway? I don't think that Elros' offspring could chose whether or not they could be mortal or immortal. They were just mortal men with really LONG lifespans.
__________________
The Party Doesn't Start Until You're Dead.
|
05-06-2009, 07:03 AM | #53 | |
Loremaster of Annúminas
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 2,317
|
Quote:
__________________
The entire plot of The Lord of the Rings could be said to turn on what Sauron didn’t know, and when he didn’t know it. |
|
05-06-2009, 10:39 AM | #54 | |
Ghost Prince of Cardolan
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 1,033
|
Quote:
The mortal (once chosen) will essentially restore the natural order of Eru without sundering child from parent, and the special dispensation given to Earendil and Elwing need not be extended yet again in this circumstance. |
|
05-06-2009, 02:45 PM | #55 | |
Spirit of Mist
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Tol Eressea
Posts: 3,364
|
I do not think that Elros' children had the option of choosing to be numbered among the Elves. Elros chose to be a mortal Man and his wife was mortal as well. The children of Elros were Men and thus could not be denied the Gift of Iluvatar. I do not think that a residual percentage of Elvish blood would change this conclusion.
The Half-Elven created a dilemna for the Valar, which was resolved by a hard and fast rule, at least for those who chose mortality. The applicable quote is Quote:
Which circles back to the original question. Did Elladan and Elrohir have this choice as well? Manwe's speech, quoted above suggests the answer here is no. The quotes attributed to Elrond, above, and the excerpts from Letters, suggest the answer may be yes. Arwen's statements are equivocal; she says that she was granted the choice of Luthien, which is a different matter altogether. Yet even Elrond's statement is somewhat equivocal. He says 'That so long as I abide here, she shall live with the youth of the Eldar (...) And when I depart, she shall go with me, if she so chooses.' While this hints at the existence of a choice, it may be that all he means is that she is an Elf and whether or not she departs with him into the West, she remains an Elf. If we accept Manwe's statement, Elrond's children have no choice. Elrond's decision is binding upon them. If this is the case, maybe only Arwen was granted the choice of Luthien. Given Elrond's grief at their parting "that should endure beyond the ends of the world", it seems clear that she is granted leave to live the life of a mortal Man. She did not merely die of grief as an Elf. Perhaps this is the simplest answer; Elladan, Elrohir and Arwen lacked the choice of the Half-Elven and Arwen's was a special case.
__________________
Beleriand, Beleriand, the borders of the Elven-land. |
|
05-06-2009, 02:53 PM | #56 | |
Late Istar
Join Date: Mar 2001
Posts: 2,224
|
Quote:
I think that in light of that fact, it's much easier to suppose that Manwe's speech is to be amended than that Tolkien's statement in Letters was blatantly false. |
|
05-06-2009, 03:30 PM | #57 |
Spirit of Mist
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Tol Eressea
Posts: 3,364
|
Manwe's speech is from the Silmarillion, as published for what it's worth. I have not checked any of Tolkien's post-LoTR drafts to see if this speech appears.
This is, of course, the difficulty in attempting to analyse this and many other issues in any of Tolkien's writings beyond the Hobbit and LoTR. We can drive ourselves crazy arguing about whether CT's Silmarillion is in any way "authoratative', and what JRRT intended and when. Letter 153 dates to 1954 and discusses Elladan and Elrohir delaying their choice and attributes the choice to all of the Half-Elven. This Letter also states that Elros' choice was irrevocable and binding upon his descendants, by the way. Letter 211, from 1958, states that the names Elladan and Elrohir both signify "Elf+Man". From these references, we can make predictions about what Tolkien may ultimately have decided, but even then there is no certainty. Until a final version hits the bookshelves, he could change his mind, as he often did. The problem is he never published the Silmarillion or any of the related works found in Unfinished Tales and HoME. And the last thing I want to do now is try to decide what is "canon".
__________________
Beleriand, Beleriand, the borders of the Elven-land. |
05-06-2009, 03:44 PM | #58 | ||
Ghost Prince of Cardolan
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 1,033
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
||
05-06-2009, 04:26 PM | #59 |
Loremaster of Annúminas
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 2,317
|
Manwe's speech is from the Silmarillion, as published for what it's worth. I have not checked any of Tolkien's post-LoTR drafts to see if this speech appears.
And taken direct from QS (1937)- Tolkien never returned to the Voyage of Earendil post-LR (save some cursory name-changes). The work of the Fifties only got as far as Turin's death (+Hurin in Brethil).
__________________
The entire plot of The Lord of the Rings could be said to turn on what Sauron didn’t know, and when he didn’t know it. |
05-06-2009, 08:40 PM | #60 |
Ghost Prince of Cardolan
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 1,033
|
And WCH means the speech in the constructed Silmarillion is direct from the 1937 Silmarillion (Manwe's speech), but not exactly, as (for example) the part I refer to (and WCH quoted)...
'Now all those who have the blood of mortal Men, in whatever part, great or small, are mortal, unless other doom be granted to them...' ... is not in the 1977 version. |
05-06-2009, 09:36 PM | #61 |
Loremaster of Annúminas
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 2,317
|
You're right, Galin, I should have checked. But in that case, CT left off that bit precisely because he deemed it to conflict with what JRRT later wrote re Elrond's children.
__________________
The entire plot of The Lord of the Rings could be said to turn on what Sauron didn’t know, and when he didn’t know it. |
05-06-2009, 10:08 PM | #62 | |
Ghost Prince of Cardolan
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 1,033
|
Quote:
Last edited by Galin; 05-09-2009 at 08:30 PM. |
|
05-06-2009, 10:17 PM | #63 |
Loremaster of Annúminas
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 2,317
|
No, it's just my surmise: but I reckon it would be seen as 'superseded' after Elrond's children were invented and an extended Choice into the third generation added.
__________________
The entire plot of The Lord of the Rings could be said to turn on what Sauron didn’t know, and when he didn’t know it. |
05-06-2009, 10:22 PM | #64 |
Ghost Prince of Cardolan
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 1,033
|
Oh, OK.
I'm sure Christopher Tolkien had his reasons, but maybe they were something other than having to do with Elrond's children? maybe Elrond's children would have been 'default mortal' (by having some measure of mortal blood), but yet they had other doom extended to them? Last edited by Galin; 05-09-2009 at 08:31 PM. |
05-06-2009, 10:27 PM | #65 | |
Wight
Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 204
|
Quote:
Which brings me back to a point that may bear on Elrohir and Elladan's decision (assuming they had one). Why would they choose to be mortal? In the case of both Arwen and Luthien, it seems to be a case where love for a mortal man is stronger than the desire for immortality, but it is not particularly clear what the attraction for Elrohir and Elladan would be. Although the same could be said for Elros... It is not stated what happened to the two brothers, but it seems that they would have been mentioned somewhere in the Tale of Aragorn and Arwen if they were still around 120 years after Elrond left. The same might be said of Celeborn, however, since one would think that Arwen might seek out her grandfather at this point. The implication is that all of the High Elves were gone by this time...
__________________
`These are indeed strange days,' he muttered. `Dreams and legends spring to life out of the grass.' |
|
05-06-2009, 11:20 PM | #66 | ||
Wight
Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 204
|
On the subject of Arwen's death (or the reason for it), I take it as being similar to the acceptance of death by Aragorn himself, and his Numenorean ancestors. They because weary with life and gave it up at some level willingly, that is, without descending into decrepitude and senility. It is said in The Tale of Aragorn and Arwen that initially
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
`These are indeed strange days,' he muttered. `Dreams and legends spring to life out of the grass.' |
||
05-07-2009, 06:25 AM | #67 |
Pilgrim Soul
Join Date: May 2004
Location: watching the wonga-wonga birds circle...
Posts: 9,455
|
If Arwen were mortal by default then the doom of Luthien is irrelevant. She is mortal, falls in love with a mortal. No big deal. The terrible doom would be Elrond's (as was presumably Mithrellas) to be the immortal parent of mortal children.
__________________
“But Finrod walks with Finarfin his father beneath the trees in Eldamar.”
Christopher Tolkien, Requiescat in pace |
05-07-2009, 08:04 AM | #68 | |
Ghost Prince of Cardolan
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 1,033
|
Quote:
'Now all those who have the blood of mortal Men, in whatever part, great or small, are mortal, unless other doom be granted to them...' But he adds: 'in this matter the power of doom is given to me. This is my decree: to Earendil and to Elwing and to their sons...' which appears to say he is given power in this matter to grant a doom other than that which would normally occur (both Earendil and Elwing were 'potential immortals' once given the choice, and as it happens, they both chose immortality). Much later Tolkien writes (albeit in draft): 2300 '(...) These children were three parts Elven-race, but the doom spoken at their birth was that they should live even as Elves so long as their father remained in Middle-earth; but if he departed they should have then the choice either to pass over the Sea with him, or to become mortal, if they remained behind.' OK, they had some measure of mortal blood anyway, and should have been mortal by default -- but they were not mortal or immortal by default by virtue of being given a choice -- and had they not been granted other doom they would have been automatically sundered from their parents in fate (and note that all these beings with mortal blood are not being withheld the gift of God). In any event we have Tolkien-published text that all three children were given the choice. So, for myself, I see no necessary conflict here (so far! that is), and have been submitting the idea that if Manwe's speech was still in play, then Elros' children were also default mortal -- but they need not be given the choice, for his choice (and he must be free to choose mortality or immortality without notable constraint in the first place, to have a true and fair enough choice to begin with), once made, meant that they would not be automatically sundered from their parents while (basically) the natural order of Eru was restored in that line -- the 'natural order' as illuminated by Manwe (QS, Lost Road version) before he pronounced that he could yet give special dispensation in the specific matter at hand. And the power to do so, I think, must have come from Eru. Last edited by Galin; 05-07-2009 at 04:46 PM. |
|
05-07-2009, 08:29 AM | #69 | |
Wight
Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 204
|
Rather than being "mortal by default", the statement seems to be that they have the life of the Eldar by default based on what Elrond says in Appendix A:
Quote:
__________________
`These are indeed strange days,' he muttered. `Dreams and legends spring to life out of the grass.' |
|
05-07-2009, 08:39 AM | #70 | ||
Gruesome Spectre
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Heaven's doorstep
Posts: 8,036
|
Quote:
Quote:
Perhaps Elros (or the sons of Elrond) would have had similar thoughts.
__________________
Music alone proves the existence of God. |
||
05-07-2009, 09:47 AM | #71 | |
Ghost Prince of Cardolan
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 1,033
|
Quote:
'But there will be no choice before Arwen, my beloved, unless you, Aragorn, Arathorn's son, come between us and bring one of us, you or me, to a bitter parting beyond the end of the world.' As I read it this can easily mean that Arwen will have no reason to choose mortality -- in other words, Elrond knows his daughter, and thus knows she will likely pass Over Sea with him if Aragorn were not in the picture. Aragorn has just said (directly before this) that the choice must soon be laid on your children, and Elrond responded 'Truly'... and then goes on to say the part you quoted. This fits with the earlier statement in Appendix A. Arwen is not default immortal nor default mortal by virtue of the choice -- and Luthien is an exception. Arwen's choice merely echoes that of Luthien's, and she would have arguably chosen an Elven fate had not Aragorn been in the picture (again, which is what I glean from the quote you posted). Theoretically 'a mortal' of course, but as the history turned out, specifically Aragorn and Beren. |
|
05-07-2009, 10:12 PM | #72 | |
Wight
Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 204
|
Quote:
Otherwise, I might have guessed that there was something about the Elven life that left the individuals disconnected--Elros, for example, was offered a chance to rule a kingdom. The argument against would be that Elrond was able to found and lead Rivendell for thousands of years, although at the end of the Third Age certainly the Elves were marginalized. Perhaps initially the important role for Elrond beyond that of a mostly spiritual and scholarly life was less clear. For Arwen, it would also be a choice between going to the Undying Lands or having some part in ruling a kingdom of men. Even before the First Age, we see Galadriel getting antsy to strike out on her own and rule a kingdom, which is one of the explanations for her leaving for Middle Earth in the first place.
__________________
`These are indeed strange days,' he muttered. `Dreams and legends spring to life out of the grass.' |
|
05-08-2009, 08:04 AM | #73 | |
Ghost Prince of Cardolan
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 1,033
|
Well, it's a mortal perspective that sometimes puts the Elvish longevity ('immortality' of the Elves) above the gift of God to Men, but also, there is the idea that the gift will come to be envied by the Elves, and 'which as Time wears even the Powers shall envy' (from The Silmarillion, chapter Of The Beginning Of Days).
In letter 156 (1954) Tolkien wrote that in the view of the myth, Death, or the mere shortness of human life-span, is not a punishment for the Fall, and: 'The attempt to escape it is wicked because 'unnatural', and silly because death in that sense is the Gift of God (envied by the Elves), release from the weariness of Time.' And in 1958, draft letter 212: Quote:
After the Athrabeth, Tolkien makes the point that it is a conversation, and it may have some interest for men who start with similar beliefs or assumptions to those held by the Elvish King Finrod. And it is specifically said that the Elves, observing that all Men died (a fact confirmed by Men), held that death was natural, and that the fear (plural of fea) of Men left Time sooner or later, and never returned. More generally, in 1956 Tolkien explained (letter 186): 'The real theme for me is about something much more permanent and difficult: Death and Immortality: the mystery of the love of the world in the hearts of a race 'doomed' to leave and seemingly lose it; the anguish in the hearts of a race 'doomed' not to leave it, until its whole evil-aroused story is complete.' And in his essay on Fairy Stories: 'And lastly there is the oldest and deepest desire, the Great Escape: the Escape from Death. Fairy-stories provide many examples and modes of this (...) Fairy-stories are made by men not by fairies. The Human-stories of the elves are doubtless full of the Escape from Deathlessness.' And it might be added too that immortality is the natural state of the Elves of course, and Tolkien refers to this also as a special gift to them: 'Immortality and Mortality being the special gifts of God to the Eruhini (...) it must be assumed that no alteration of their fundamental kind could be effected by the Valar even in one case: the cases of Luthien (and Tuor) and the position of their descendants was a direct act of God.' These last two bits of information come once again from the famed letter 153 -- I note this considering that I think, in the books, Tolkien has a least implied the Sons of Elrond chose mortality -- versus this letter where he says they delayed their choice after Elrond left, but what can I do. Last edited by Galin; 06-08-2009 at 06:41 AM. |
|
05-09-2009, 10:30 AM | #74 |
Shade of Carn Dûm
Join Date: Jun 2007
Posts: 435
|
A thought occurs to me, if (as some suggested) elros's children should have been elegible for "the choice" (I'm not saying they were, only that some of those on the board suggested they should have been being part elf) that shouln't Eldarion have had the same opportunity? After all he was also part elf. In fact he is slightly more elf than Elros's children they are 1/4 and he is 3/8 or more accurately very slighty more than 3/8 (the "slightly more is becuse if Aragorn is a descendent of decendent of the Kings of Numernor, he has a few dribbles of Elros's blood in him too. How much however, can't be accurety determined for a simple reason, namely that while his paternal amount could be determined ( 1/2 to the n where n is the number of gererations between Aragorn and Elros) it's a fair bet that after a few generations many of the Numernorian ancestors would have took wives who were distant relatives (Numernor didn't have a huge population, and royal/noble families tend to inbreed quite a bit anyway whether by law or custom) and who would have varios amounts of Elros's blood in them too so to get the true amount in Eldarion you'd need to know all of his female ancestors geneologies as well.)
|
05-30-2009, 11:27 PM | #75 |
Spirit of Mist
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Tol Eressea
Posts: 3,364
|
Before letting this issue go, I want to take one last shot at making sense of the matter. Rather than trying to interpret snippets of text, I'd like to look at the issue dispassionately based upon lineage and parentage, as, presumably, the Valar would have needed to look at the issue when they decided it at the end of the First Age.
Beren was a Man. Luthien, despite her lineage by birth, received leave to be counted as mortal and returned to Beleriand with Beren... "for a time". Both were mortal. Dior was a Man, not a Half-Elf. Tuor and Idril begot Earendil, a true Half-Elf. Dior wedded Nimloth, an Elf, and begot Elwing, a Half-Elf. Elrond and Elros, sons of Earendil and Elwing were true mixed bloods, and were given leave to choose. Elros chose to be a Man and married... whatever her name was, a Man, and begot Mannish children and descendents. Elrond, who chose to be an Elf, married Celebrian, an Elf. Their Children are... Elves. Arwen is given the choice of Luthien and chooses to be numbered among the Men. Elladan and Elrohir have no such choice, they are Elves. Pick the logic apart people!
__________________
Beleriand, Beleriand, the borders of the Elven-land. |
05-31-2009, 09:18 AM | #76 | ||||
Loremaster of Annúminas
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 2,317
|
The hypothesis (that E&E are simply Elves and have no choice) founders on the data:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
It doesn't matter that E&E are 78% Elvish by descent- the Mannish element in their lineage cannot be ignored or denied, save by their own free choice.
__________________
The entire plot of The Lord of the Rings could be said to turn on what Sauron didn’t know, and when he didn’t know it. Last edited by William Cloud Hicklin; 05-31-2009 at 09:27 AM. |
||||
05-31-2009, 12:33 PM | #77 |
Ghost Prince of Cardolan
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 1,033
|
I agree with WCH on that -- and there's another letter too, where Tolkien states that Arwen was not an Elf. But The Letters of JRR Tolkien is proving a mixed bag for me on this issue in general. Also, I believe (correct me if I'm wrong) that the two mentions (and only mentions?) that confirm Elladan and Elrohir remained behind after Elrond sailed were only added to the revised edition of The Lord of the Rings in the 1960s.
Not that that proves anything of course, but if true might give a better idea of the chronology anyway. |
05-31-2009, 03:24 PM | #78 |
Spirit of Mist
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Tol Eressea
Posts: 3,364
|
One last post to this thread, then I will say no more on this issue. The problem I have here is not that I necessarily disagree with the textual analyses that have been ably set forth by various members here. Rather, my issue is simply that one of the great appeals that Middle Earth has for me is its internal inconsistency, and here is one point where it is inconsistent. The children of Elrond and Elros all genetically possess elements of Mannish blood, assuming the "science of genetics" bears any real relevancy to the interpretation of mythology. To me, this means they should all be treated the same unless there is a good reason to the contrary.
The analysis I set forth in my last post explains the state of matters as we see them in LoTR. The problem is that the solution I outline is not what Tolkien appears to have settled upon. Rather, he treats the children of Elros and Elrond differently because... well just because. The importance of the Eru's gift cannot be the answer for why similarly situated persons are treated differently; Elrond's children have less Mannish blood than those of Elros, but based upon the analyses of multiple posters here, the presence of any Mannish blood is significant. I suggest that genetics and the presence of physical Mannish blood does not determine this issue, else both sets of cousins would have possessed the choice regardless of the choice of their sires. Further Tolkien, in Laws and Customs Among the Eldar makes it clear that "[f]rom the beginning the chief difference between Elves and Men lay in the fate and nature of their spirits" The fëar of Men and Elves determine their fundamental nature, not their hroar or bodies. The fëar of Elves "far excelled over the spirits of Men in power over that 'raiment', even from the first days protecting their bodies from many ills and assaults (such as disease), and healing them swiftly of injuries, so that they recovered from wounds that would have proved fatal to Men." It is the fëar that determine the nature of Men and Elves, not their bodies or their blood. When Half-Elven make their choice, it is a change to the spirits not to their bodies. So genetics has nothing to do with the effect of a Half-Elf's choice over the nature of their offspring. Elros' fëa was mortal as was his wife's and, accordingly, his children's spirits were Mannish. Elrond and Celebrian's fëar were Elvish. Why should the spirits of their children be otherwise. This is the problem I have here.
__________________
Beleriand, Beleriand, the borders of the Elven-land. |
05-31-2009, 04:56 PM | #79 | ||
Late Istar
Join Date: Mar 2001
Posts: 2,224
|
Mithadan wrote:
Quote:
One can perhaps dispute that account by calling into question the validity of Tolkien's statements in Letters and elsewhere, but I do not think one can make the charge of inconsistency in it. It coheres and it agrees with what is said in LotR. Quote:
But as for your question - is there necessarily anything problematic with the fea of the child differing from the fear of the parents? Certainly, there's no logical impossibility involved there. And, apparently, Tolkien didn't feel that there was a metaphysical impossibility either. There's also an interesting supposition behind your argument here: that there are Elvish fear and there are Mannish fear, and that Elvishness or Mannishness is an intrinsic, perhaps unalterable, attribute of the spirit. I think we must question to what extent this is true. Yes, human spirits leave Arda after death while Elvish spirits do not; but does this imply any particular difference between the two classes of spirits themselves, beyond the difference in their ultimate fates? It seems plain, at least, that the Elvishness or Mannishness of a fea could be changed: Luthien provides an unambiguous case of an Elvish spirit becoming Mannish. When this happened, Luthien's soul, her will, her consciousness did not change. She had the same fea before and after; only its fate was different. I suggest that a fea itself is not intrinsically Elvish or Mannish, though in most cases a particular fate is attached to it the moment it enters the world, due to its parentage. But that fate could be altered (as in Luthien's case); and in the case of Elrond's children, to whom the choice was granted even before they were born, neither fate would be prescribed to the fea when it first entered the world. |
||
09-29-2012, 10:21 AM | #80 |
Spirit of Mist
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Tol Eressea
Posts: 3,364
|
1
__________________
Beleriand, Beleriand, the borders of the Elven-land. |
|
|