Elrond and Sauron, a personal vendetta?

[Aganzir]

Originally Posted by Dwarven Warrior

Well, wasn't Sauron responsible for that, or in the very least Sauron's servants?

Were all the orcs Sauron's servants all the time? I don't think so. They fought for Sauron but that doesn't mean he commanded every single orc that lived in the Misty Mountains and other places.

Originally Posted by Dwarven Warrior

Morgoth is out of the way, he's already being punished for his sins. Sauron on the other hand is still alive and working against not only him but also his entire race!

Melkor was the one to start it all. If not for Melkor, would Sauron still be happily in Aman, serving Aulë? Maybe. If a criminal attacks you and robs all your money, do you hate him more than the boss of the gang whose fault the attack, after all, was?

Originally Posted by Groin

True, very true. I did say that there were exceptions, but I doubt she could be as mean spirited as Elrond could have been.

Bah. Elrond is a timid girl compared to Galadriel.
(No need to start arguing about that, I know the facts.)