Tol-in-Guarhoth CIX - Ten Year Anniversary Game: Dead Thread

[the phantom]

Endless possibilities. We know nothing!

[the phantom]

But time to actually get serious and try a bit of thinking. Need to see what if any implications there are with this Boro reveal...

[the phantom]

I wonder if Boro has any extra abilities (kill only works when offing a Wolf? gets to scry? etc.).

I ask because the Lalaith kill might've been rather risky unless he knew something, given that she agreed with both of the Wolf-dreams even before Nerwen revealed them.

[Loslote]

Originally Posted by the phantom

I wonder if Boro has any extra abilities (kill only works when offing a Wolf? gets to scry? etc.).

It looks like something of the kind, since he wasn't sure if he was, in fact, responsible for her death. He did ask the Dead thread to check her, though, so maybe it only works when offing someone with a special role (i.e., wolf or Gifted, in this game)? And that might explain why he chose Lalaith - he would've wanted to chose someone who could have been a wolf but could not have been a Gifted, and Lalaith would fit that description decently well.

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Boro

I'm saying I'm responsible for the 3rd kill (Mac) on NIGHT 3, and that I also had a decision to make on to take someone else out last night, and decided Lalaith. But I have no way of confirming whether she's a wolf (and so I would request for the dead to check her on their next chance), or if I was wrong and one pack made the same selection.

Ah, I guess that can be taken for confirmation on how the role functions. It only works if he gets a Wolf.

That makes Mac a guarantee, but we don't know about Lalaith since there were only two kills.

[Rikae]

So... done watching that awfulness. These days it's really only morbid curiosity that keeps me watching. Anyway...

Boro's reveal doesn't ring true. One or both of he & Nerwen are lying. Nerwen gets special dreams, plus Boro gets free wolf-assassinations? Nah, not buying that.

[the phantom]

Unless both strange events are a result of Boro. (Upon successful Wolf-kill the Seer's dreams go to someone else?)

But of course the more obvious possibility is that Nerwen pretended to be an Ordo receiving dreams to cover her own Seership.

[Loslote]

Originally Posted by the phantom

Endless possibilities. We know nothing!

We can't even be pretentious philosophers about it, because we don't necessarily even know that we know nothing. The whole thing is just really bad.