Ten Year Anniversary Game: Living Thread

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

That's not conclusive, though, because the clause about the other Lover remaining alive is unclear - remains alive until when? I would guess it means that s/he must remain alive until the moment the first Lover can return to the Living; but it might also mean that the lynched Lover's journey between worlds can take place on the condition that the other Lover is alive when the lynching takes place - regardless of what happens afterwards.

[Boromir88]

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

That's not conclusive, though, because the clause about the other Lover remaining alive is unclear - remains alive until when? I would guess it means that s/he must remain alive until the moment the first Lover can return to the Living; but it might also mean that the lynched Lover's journey between worlds can take place on the condition that the other Lover is alive when the lynching takes place - regardless of what happens afterwards.

Oi. This time we might need those odds-crunchers.

If the Ranger is still alive and able to protect the other Lover to ensure one can return than it might be worth it. Would it be worth it right now though, is the other question? I mean the Dead would only know of one person's role at the moment.

And I think morm is on the right track with the one piece of information we do have...Agan was the Hunter, so let's turn the focus on her voters (that's really the only conclusion you can draw from the narration...I have a hard time believing Kuru would be that cruel to mislead us with the talk of traps and arrows).

I'll go and look at 3 night deaths first. See if there's anything there. You know what's kind of amusing (and sad at the same time). the phantom still has the most posts in this thread. Rikae is the next closest, but she's dead. I'm next. Doubtful, I'll surpass him tonight, since my vacation time is over and I'll be gone for much of tomorrow. Hopefully, I can be ambitious to analyze all that I want to tonight.