new sub-forum?

[Kuruharan]

Originally Posted by Formendacil

despite having no interest or ability to participate in a game-discussions subforum, I am not so sure we don't already have precedent for such a forum.

If I've had a video game based topic to post, I've tried to use the Middle-earth Mirth section.

Originally Posted by Nerwen

I don't know... my experience of OT subforums on other sites is that they tend to devolve into conspiracy-theory battlegrounds.

Originally Posted by Morthoron

The refreshing thing about the Downs has always been its decided omission of off-topic claptrap and bilge. No need for extraneous political arguments, religious wars, stupid pet tricks and reality TV indiscretions. Just Tolkien-centric talk without the filler.

I agree, the Downs does not need an Off Topic sub-forum. We are a breath of fresh air on the Internet in not having one.

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Kuru

I agree, the Downs does not need an Off Topic sub-forum. We are a breath of fresh air on the Internet in not having one.

We all sound so bitter and jaded about this, though, don’t we?

[Mithalwen]

We were refused a sub forum to discuss the BBC Radio adaptation so don't think likely.

[Kuruharan]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

We all sound so bitter and jaded about this, though, don’t we?

I think we have all been through the wars at this point.

[tom the eldest]

Yikes,the opposition is strong.okay then.if that the members opinion,i will appreciate it

[Inziladun]

Originally Posted by tom the eldest

Yikes,the opposition is strong.okay then.if that the members opinion,i will appreciate it

Well, it isn't really a decision for members; the forum admins decide things like that.
The reigning opinion does seem to be negative, though.

[Zigûr]

Originally Posted by tom the eldest

Yikes,the opposition is strong.okay then.if that the members opinion,i will appreciate it

I think the thing is, from a purely practical standpoint there clearly isn't the interest. If people were interested in talking about the games more they would be, but even the thread about the new game died out pretty quickly.

in every new lord of the rings/the hobbit game,theres new content that is unique,and independent from the book or movie(ex:caragors,mountain giant,graugs,etc)

Regarding this, I think people don't discuss this stuff because they're not interested in it, not because they're isn't a space for it. It's Tolkien-related "new content', but it isn't "real" Tolkien. I can appreciate why the situation is different for the films because of their massive cultural presence and the greater overlap between book-readers and film-watchers than between either of those and game-players.

That being said if anyone wants to discuss 'The Battle for Middle-earth' or its sequel (or the Games Workshop toy soldier game) I'd be more than happy to join in. But I think it's clear by observation of the direction and calibre of discussion here that a whole sub-forum would be little more than a domain of cyberspace tumbleweeds and would jar with the tone of the forum as (in my opinion) a place where "Tolkien" is not the commerical enterprise that has spawned such games.

[Tar-Jêx]

Originally Posted by Zigûr

Regarding this, I think people don't discuss this stuff because they're not interested in it, not because they're isn't a space for it. It's Tolkien-related "new content', but it isn't "real" Tolkien. I can appreciate why the situation is different for the films because of their massive cultural presence and the greater overlap between book-readers and film-watchers than between either of those and game-players.

That being said if anyone wants to discuss 'The Battle for Middle-earth' or its sequel (or the Games Workshop toy soldier game) I'd be more than happy to join in. But I think it's clear by observation of the direction and calibre of discussion here that a whole sub-forum would be little more than a domain of cyberspace tumbleweeds and would jar with the tone of the forum as (in my opinion) a place where "Tolkien" is not the commerical enterprise that has spawned such games.

If the 'Tolkien' games do become a bigger thing over the years, then it may be worthy having a sub-sub-forum for it, but at the moment, they aren't that popular, and if they are, like Shadow of Mordor, then it's pretty shallow content with not much to discuss.

Imagine it like this, there are 2 (possibly more) dedicated threads to 'Riddles in the Dark'. We don't need a whole sub forum for that sort of discussion, but just some threads. We could take sort of discussion to 'New Players', but I think we should rename it, because that name isn't particularly indicative of what's there. 'New Players' deserves a sub-forum in that general 'Off topic, but still kind of relevant' sub forum.

[Leaf]

I guess the forum for the movies could be renamed as "Tolkien adaptations" or something similiar. (Video) games, movies and other popcultural adaptations could be discussed there equally.