Game Thread - WW XCIIX - The Meaning Of Death

[Loslote]

Originally Posted by the phantom

But if Nerwen turns out guilty then why not try her again? Maybe she's a turncoat KM. The secret role- the saboteur.

It doesn't really matter who he sends it to - the Dreamer would have little choice but to accurately relay the dream. If a KM receives a dream about an ordo, they can't really say "they're a KM!" because the lynch will prove otherwise very quickly. If a KM receives a dream about a fellow KM, they can't realistically say "they're innocent" because the numbers just won't bear it out - the village will quickly realize that either the Dreamer must be a KM, or the Dreamed must be. The only risky bit is if the KM dreams about a Gifted, which is something we really, really don't want.

[the phantom]

In other news- congenital egocentrical hyperplasia has been declared "The most awesome disease ever!" by the US Surgeon General.

[Morsul the Dark]

The Phantom's last three posts are interesting

Sabateour, Awesome future role for a game would be amazing.

romantic tensions eh? Sally what do yo think? me you a movie?

awesomest disease? As a sufferer I can say it is.

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Morsul the Dark

Sabateour, Awesome future role for a game would be amazing.

Been there. Done that. Fun times.

[Morsul the Dark]

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

Been there. Done that. Fun times.

I just realized I got a smiley! is the rift healing? maybe.

Moving on I have to go n five minutes(didn't realize I'd be back for even this time.

From everything happening today I think my sally vote was a jump to conclusions that being said tomorrow I'll give a more thorough read see what happens.

retracting votes isn't in the rules I assume it's not allowed?

hopefully be back before DL. If it's allowed might change my vote but stuck with it for now...\

edit: bolding

[Inziladun]

Originally Posted by the phantom

In other news- congenital egocentrical hyperplasia has been declared "The most awesome disease ever!" by the US Surgeon General.

Better known by its common name, phantomitis.

[the phantom]

Anyone reading this would swear this was Day 1.

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by the phantom

Anyone reading this would swear this was Day 1.

In semi-related news, I may actually reach 100 posts this game. That hasn't happened in....over a year, at least.

EDIT: x'd with Morsul

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Sally

and I am not a fan of easy death

Many that live deserve death. But many that die deserve life. Can you give it to them?

(It can be argued that this guy deserves it more than me.)

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Sally

Hence my suggestion that Elendil send the information to the person they suspect is the other gifted in the mix. Less(ish) risky.

How do we feel about suggesting Elendil send information about Lottie rather than to her? Just throwing the idea out there and seeing what you all think.

If you wouldn't have kept bringing it up I have no doubt that Elendil fully intended to send the dream to the other Gifted. But now that the KMs have been informed and know it's worth their time to look they're probably going to figure out the other Gifted thus making the whole thing a waste of time.

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Eonwe

Were you in my game where I did this?

I don't think so. I recall the saboteur, though.

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by the phantom

If you wouldn't have kept bringing it up I have no doubt that Elendil fully intended to send the dream to the other Gifted. But now that the KMs have been informed and know it's worth their time to look they're probably going to figure out the other Gifted thus making the whole thing a waste of time.

Given that the Night kill is almost certain to be a confirmed innocent, however, I doubt the other gifted is in much danger [edit: more danger than anyone else]. Also, if the KMs know who the other gifted is, they'll also be able to figure out who the seer is,so....really, guys, they might as well just roll a die to decide who to kill at this point. Everyone's dangerous. Everyone can reveal their role, or prove someone else innocent, or whatever.

I stand by my thought that Lottie should be the dream though. The seer's free to ignore that suggestion, of course, but I think it's for the best. Almost everyone else is known at this point.


Sweet magical cupcakes, this would be pretty anti-climactic if Lottie's been lying....

[Eönwë]

Originally Posted by the phantom

Anyone reading this would swear this was Day 1.

It basically is. There's so much chaos.

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Loslote

It doesn't really matter who he sends it to - the Dreamer would have little choice but to accurately relay the dream. If a KM receives a dream about an ordo, they can't really say "they're a KM!" because the lynch will prove otherwise very quickly. If a KM receives a dream about a fellow KM, they can't realistically say "they're innocent" because the numbers just won't bear it out - the village will quickly realize that either the Dreamer must be a KM, or the Dreamed must be. The only risky bit is if the KM dreams about a Gifted, which is something we really, really don't want.

Hence my suggestion that Elendil send the information to the person they suspect is the other gifted in the mix. Less(ish) risky.

How do we feel about suggesting Elendil send information about Lottie rather than to her? Just throwing the idea out there and seeing what you all think.

[Morsul the Dark]

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

Hence my suggestion that Elendil send the information to the person they suspect is the other gifted in the mix. Less(ish) risky.

How do we feel about suggesting Elendil send information about Lottie rather than to her? Just throwing the idea out there and seeing what you all think.

This sounds like pretty sound advice to me.

[Eönwë]

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

How do we feel about suggesting Elendil send information about Lottie rather than to her? Just throwing the idea out there and seeing what you all think.

Yeah, that sounds pretty good.