Gandalf on a white Mumak?

[Mithalwen]

Originally Posted by Inziladun

Glad you made the transition from lurking to posting, Kyledanger.

I would think Frodo's emphasis on a white oliphaunt is probably as you say, merely meant as a symbol for good.

Additionally, Frodo had before when crossing the Bruinen into Rivendell seen the white horses Gandalf had made appear in the flood, so that might have caused Frodo's association also.

There may also be an association with Glorfindel who Frodo sees first as a white rider. The albeit retrofitting of Glorfindel of Rivendell with Glorfindel of Gondolin since it meant that Glorfindel like Gandalf died to Middle Earth fighting a Balrog and was sent back. It was Glorifindel who made the prophecy about the Witch King that was soon to be fulfilled by Eowyn and Merry.

However I think the primary reason is the "cowboy film rule" of good guys having white hats and the baddies black hats.

But interesting topic. I don't ever remember reading this which suggests it is high time I read the book all through instead of "dipping".