Werewolf XCVII: Werewolves in the Westfold Game Thread

[Kitanna]

Sally
1: Normal Sally day 1, post 1.
2:

Obviously Nessa did it. She was found at the scene, after all.

Maybe Sally's the real seer and Zil and I are just playing an elaborate prank. Comments that maybe we'll lynch a wolf by sheer dumb luck.
3: Responds to my comment about how dumb luck won't work because Boro isn't in this game and she's not a wolf.
4: Looks at the odds and decides the dumb luck comment maybe wasn't entirely false. Lists who she won't be voting for based on usual Sally nonsense.
5: Banter
6: IC
7: Votes for me. I don't appreciated my name being used near the word "creep", thank you very much. Sounds like she drew a name out of a hat to vote.
Day 2:
8: Makes an interesting point that Nessa's vote makes her look bad and Pitch look good. Not so sure I agree with it.
9: Angry at seer shenanigans. She'll comment later.
It grieves me to say so, 'cause Sally is always high on my list, but for once she doesn't look bad. She hasn't really sad anything that suggests anything other than a frustrated innocent crunched for time.

G55
1: Mostly "I'm alive, but will be back"
2: Responds to a few of Coppermirror's questions observations (Day 1 is mostly banter, especially early and explains the sub-hunter) Doesn't like Sally's vote, but doesn't blame her.
3: Summarizes how she feels about everyone. Continues her dislike of Sally's vote, but understands why she voted as she did. Her two top suspects are Nerwen (for having a feeling about her) and Shasta, because she's worried of him flying under the radar. Seems like Nerwen will get her vote.
4: Dislikes Nessa's vote, feels it is too easy to hide behind.

We judge people by their votes. How are we supposed to judge a person whose vote is not only a throwaway, but also for a person who in no way warrated it because he's not even there?!

A very good point.
5: Votes Nessa.
Not sure what to make of G55. She hasn't spoke up yet today and of her top suspects (Nessa, Nerwen, and Shasta) two are dead and one isn't around yet either. I can see G55-wolf steering votes toward a packmate, but I don't know if I can see it on Day 1. I do find it interesting so many of her suspects have wound up dead.

Eomer
1: Banter
2: Apparently Coppermirror drowns cats. I'm glad I caught this post. I needed a laugh.
3: Makes an interesting scenario out of Zil's "vague feelings", Sally's vote, and Nerwen's attack of Sally's vote.
4: Believes killing Sally is always an option.
5: Recounts the votes so far.
6: Questions Zil's baiting Coppermirror tactic and isn't sure how Zil can figure Nessa or Nerwen's role by my death.
7: If Zil is a wolf, Sally is probably not.
8: Against the Nessa bandwagon, but not for her vote either.
9: Votes Sally.
Day 2:
10: Vote tally.
11: I'll have to reread Zil's post that led to this, but he decides Zil's suspicion of me is genuine. Still thinks it's weird.
12: Response to seer reveals.
At first I wasn't sure what to think of Eomer, but I believe he may well be wolf #3. He distanced himself from the Nessa bandwagon well, but also kept packmate Zil in his sights as a possibility at all times. This way when Zil goes down Eomer can hide behind his earlier suspicions. Whatever happens today I think a closer watch should be kept on him.

Pitch
1: Making up for missed Day 1 banter. Puts down some scenarios for Nessa's vote and vote placement. Asks Copper why she thought Nerwen was a possibly seer.
2: Responds to some of Zil's comments.
3: Response to Sally's post 8.
4: Further response to Copper's various scenarios.
5: Tells Copper I did just do a seer reveal.
6: Asks me to tell my dream.
7: Is unsurprised that someone else seer revealed.
8:

Withholding this benefit from us just because we don't trust you blindly would be dereliction of duty in a Seer.

I am being quite angry with this village and am going to keep my dream to myself. It's thanks to Zil who refuses to go down, but just wants to confuse things. I'm frustrated and angry. I also have nothing to lose but my own life at this point.
9: Believes Zil is the most seerish villager, but isn't ready to vote for me on the off chance I'm telling the truth.
10:

And if we lynch Zil and find him genuine, the point will be moot anyway, is that it?

*shrug* Neither one of us will live past Day 3 anyway.

Pitch is probably innocent.

[Inziladun]

Kudos to Kitwolf for the prodigious effort!

I personally think Coppermirror and G55 are probably innocent.
The former for general good sense, and the latter for the vote on Nessa, which seems unnecessary for a packmate of hers.

Sally doesn't strike me as a likely wolf. Her vote on Kit I put in the same boat as G55's on Nessa: not needed and too dangerous.

Shasta? Well, once again why vote for Nessawolf? Granted, as I said, Nessa's vote for Pitch looked pretty darned fishy, but still, it seems he could have found some other option to buy his mate another Day. I mistrust him in general, though, so it's rather difficult to be objective.

Pitch himself is enigmatic. I do like his skepticism in trying to sort between Kit and me, though it's still so strange to me that Nessa went for him over everyone else. Was it just a throwaway from a wolf wanting to keep above the fray? Or a wolf feeling safe in voting for a mate who hadn't made an appearance all Day and was thus a very unlikely lynch?

And that leaves Eomer. It seemed to me that he was deliberately not understanding what I'd said about my intentions with Coppermirror and Kit, and his vote for Sally could be his picking up on what Nerwen had said, trying to divert things away from Nessa. Rather trips the radar.

[Pitchwife]

Just a note before I leave:

Originally Posted by Inziladun

Shasta? Well, once again why vote for Nessawolf? Granted, as I said, Nessa's vote for Pitch looked pretty darned fishy, but still, it seems he could have found some other option to buy his mate another Day.

Shasta voted Nessa before she voted me. He was laconic enough about his reasons, but if I understand him right, he was going exclusively on the latching-on point mentioned by Nerwen.

Good night, and á vala Manwë.

[Pitchwife]

I have to vote now, as it's bedtime for me and I most likely won't be able to come online again before DL (which is near the end of my workday).

I hate this whole situation, and if Kit's a wolf, she does the angry frustrated innocent part really well. Also I concur with some of her analyses, most notably those of Cop (whom I think more probably innocent, however) and Eomer (funny, since I considered him a likely packmate for a Kitwolf earlier).

How likely is it, though, that a Zilwolf just happened to random-suspect our seer, of all people, in a seerish-looking way? Also, how much danger of getting lynched toDay was Kit really in prior to her reveal? (Yes, I mentioned her as a possible packmate of Nessa's in my first post, and the thought that Zil was the seer and had dreamed her had crossed my mind, but his continuing existence among the living cast a lot of doubt on that.) What I'm saying is wolvish guilt may have led her to underestimate her chances.

I really think it makes more sense the other way 'round, and Kitwolf is sacrificing herself in order to take down the seer before he can dream her last packmate.

Therefore
++Kitanna

Zil, if you're a wolf, well done. Kit, if you're a wolf, that was a brave attempt; if you're the real seer, may we meet in the flesh some day so you can slap me to your heart's content.

[satansaloser2005]

Pitch and I really need to stop agreeing. And yes, I'm using the word creepy again, 'cause it's getting to those levels. But, you know, maybe we're just right.

++Kit

For the record, Eomer strikes me as the first choice for the other wolf, but I don't think he'd be so bold as to vote me after I voted Kit. I don't know. I'm not thinking too much into all this until we see the results of toDay's lynch. If I'm wrong, I will be ever so cross (and also probably dead)....

Ugh. I wish I knew more toDay. >.<

[Kitanna]

I already voted but
++Kit

I have a headahce. Just don't kill Sally. She's my other packmate.