Mandos Thread: DEAD ONLY! - WW LXXXVI

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Also I would like, very much, for them to lynch Nog today. Agan thinks he's a baddie as much as I do, but if she doesn't vote for him then I may vote to double the vote of someone that has.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Or, I wonder if Glirdan set me up? That wouldn't surprise me, given that post of his - "oh I've seen Shasta act like this before and that time he was the Seer" - he's another I wouldn't mind seeing get the axe. Jerk.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

But hey, when there's no one to hear you scream (except other ghosts) then you can be as loud as you want to!

Where is everyone? I'm lonely and want to discuss... things.

[Rikae]

I originally wanted to make the votes retractable, but forgot to mention it, and now I don't think it would be fair to change it a Day in, so: no retractions.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Originally Posted by Rikae

I originally wanted to make the votes retractable, but forgot to mention it, and now I don't think it would be fair to change it a Day in, so: no retractions.

Well, this is still the first time there'd be any voting in the dead thread, but I can see how not having stated in the rules you might be leery of putting that in after the fact. Okay.

[Rikae]

True, but in that case I should probably change it for the living, too.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Originally Posted by Rikae

True, but in that case I should probably change it for the living, too.

I don't think it would make much difference if the dead votes were retractable and the living votes weren't - the living votes are much more important, after all. But I'm cool with them being nonretractable too.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Oh, Phantom. Of course you're going to try and head off a Nogwagon before it starts - he was your strongest supporter yesterday. You're doing nothing but making sure your own tail is safe by defending Nog. I hope people can see that.

[Mänwe]

Not for want of drudging up the topic but,

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

Whatever... I am so remembering why I haven't played for so long.

I've noticed a distinct difference in atmosphere from the last game in some quarters..I hope it doesn't engulf the campsite.

~~

Ah Shasta, welcome, so i'll have company for today only..does that mean I speak with a lover or the great Glorf I wonder, well time will tell. Still you'll be back again shortly if you speak amongst the living...I wonder oh mod-Valar, will [B]Shasta[/B ]when returned to the living have to post and vote?

Originally Posted by Shastanis Althreduin

Of course you're going to try and head off a Nogwagon before it starts...You're doing nothing but making sure your own tail is safe by defending Nog. I hope people can see that.

It does look a little like that. But wouldn't it have been safer to wait for someone else to post first, deriding the Nogwagon as would surely happen, before doing so himself?

Originally Posted by Shastanis Althreduin

Hi, Manwe. I'll be going back to the land of the living in a little bit, anything you care to tell me?

{my bold}

Not much apart from i've no gift, no evil and will remain in these halls. Lommy being questioned about a vote so early and for me is fine, if I were Lommy (or anyone else) I would have targeted a Mänwe too; two wolves played a quiet game last time and i've always stressed the need to try a lynching of a quiet player on the off (a shame on this occasion they're wrong again and this might benefit evil as folk may skip voting quiet players for a few days). Plus, at the moment she's playing like she did last game and she was an innocent, so it might be worth watching how people develop any case against her today.

Your issues with Nog well..his behaviour is a little suspect, trying to ellicit discord and temper in the camp wouldn't help (if he were an ordo)..and theres his reply to your reaction where he didn't attempt to diffuse the situation. He calls out that reaction, during a post where he voted for you..and this came after you voted for him so his own reaction makes him more suspect, especially as he goes on to vote for you.

and phantom i'm inclined to think ordo or phobbler.

Can't add anything about others just yet.