WW: LXXXIV - Middle Earth in Fifteen Minutes

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

Don't get me wrong though. Unless we have better ideas, let's go for the wolves with all we have. If not for anything else, it's according to the spirit of the game.

The problem - if you haven't thoiught about it - is that if we lynch a wolf we don't know we have done that, and thus we can't make any deductions on the basis of the relations that the lynched "role-haver" had with others + we'll have a "newborn" wolf which are always the hardest to hunt down as you can't use the first Days as basis of trying to figure them out.

That's the beauty of killing the hunter, as Inzi pointed out. We would know exactly where we stand.

We don't have that with the guardian, though I accept it would be preferable.