T-I-G LXVII: The Rangers of the North - The Fell Winter - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Kath · 09-22-2009, 03:42 PM

Erm, I'm a little confused Nog sorry. Your post was timestamped 10:25 so 15 or 50 minutes on from then?

Anyway here's the rest of toDay looked at (in far less detail due to the 'Downs misbehaving) along with a vote summary. I need to get to bed soon so I'll vote after I've posted this.

Legate – I actually really like his reasoning for making quiet people NGs. It is a good way to get them more involved.

Boro – er, I’m not sure. Basically ‘vote your top suspect’, which is fine if obvious, but not always feasible if voting your top suspect becomes utterly pointless if other people already have three votes and no one else suspects your suspect. Thinks Valier suspicious. Haha! A cross role hint! I was wondering how long it would take to get one of those.

Nienna – does even longer lists than me!

Inzil – suspects Hakon a bit for saying why he should be captain (I presume he means the innocent bit).

Nerwen – little bit suspicious of Rune for gunning for captain. Suspicious of Fea for not being aggressive enough.

Greenie – same thoughts as me about making a quiet person captain.

Roa – a no show during the Day might be a no show during the Night and thus could do no damage. Ok, I see her point.

Valier – getting a bad vibe from Nienna.

By the way Rune I know! I was planning on keeping a very close eye out for the start of the game given that it is Nog’s. I think I made my missing Day 1 case well while I was there but I thought I should try even harder than usual not to do it!

Aha votes! So:

Captain:
Boro --> Rune
Sally --> Legate
Greenie --> Legate
Nerwen --> Roa
Valier --> Rune
Lottie --> Rune
Roa --> Legate
Rune --> Rune
Fea --> Roa
Inzil --> Rune
Nienna --> Legate
Lommy --> Roa
Mac --> Kath

NG
Boro --> Inzil
Sally --> Valier
Inzil --> Boro
Roa --> Brinniel
Nerwen --> Kath
Lottie --> Boro
Rune --> Valier
Valier --> Roa
Fea --> Nienna
Nienna --> Roa
Lommy --> Valier
Mac --> Brinn

Lynch
Rune --> Legate
Roa --> Rune
Nerwen --> Boro
Fea --> Hakon
Sally --> Rune
Nienna --> Rune
Lottie --> Nienna
Greenie --> Hakon

Nogrod · 09-22-2009, 03:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kath

Erm, I'm a little confused Nog sorry. Your post was timestamped 10:25 so 15 or 50 minutes on from then?

You still have a half an hour exactly now... (well 28 minutes...)

You Brits never learn that with the Daylight-savings your time is not the GMT but GMT+1... (it's a deja-vu -experience...)

Old imperialistic load that is?

Kath · 09-22-2009, 03:53 PM

Cross posted since Greenie's vote.

Anyway:

++ROA for Captain

I think Roa is a good candidate. She is clearly around, engaged and looks to be playing well. I think she's a good first choice.

++ BRINN for Guard

It's been too long since I've played with her properly and I don't want to see her gone so early.

++ VALIER

I would rather not vote for her because it is her first game in a while but at the moment I don't like the way she is acting. She has just voted for a newbie who hasn't seemed suspicious to me so far and seems to have jumped onto suspicion of Lottie overly quickly. So far as I can work out, she is suspecting Lottie because she is following other people's suspicions rather than coming up with her own. Yet Valier wasn't suspicious of Lottie until Roa brought it up. So it just seems fishy to me.

Right, posting this, will check everything is highlighted and/or bolded correctly and will then disappear.

Kath · 09-22-2009, 03:54 PM

Oh and Nog - I just forget when we're actually IN daylight savings time!

09-22-2009, 03:42 PM	#1
Kath Everlasting Whiteness Join Date: Jan 2004 Location: Perusing the laminated book of dreams Posts: 4,533	Erm, I'm a little confused Nog sorry. Your post was timestamped 10:25 so 15 or 50 minutes on from then? Anyway here's the rest of toDay looked at (in far less detail due to the 'Downs misbehaving) along with a vote summary. I need to get to bed soon so I'll vote after I've posted this. Legate – I actually really like his reasoning for making quiet people NGs. It is a good way to get them more involved. Boro – er, I’m not sure. Basically ‘vote your top suspect’, which is fine if obvious, but not always feasible if voting your top suspect becomes utterly pointless if other people already have three votes and no one else suspects your suspect. Thinks Valier suspicious. Haha! A cross role hint! I was wondering how long it would take to get one of those. Nienna – does even longer lists than me! Inzil – suspects Hakon a bit for saying why he should be captain (I presume he means the innocent bit). Nerwen – little bit suspicious of Rune for gunning for captain. Suspicious of Fea for not being aggressive enough. Greenie – same thoughts as me about making a quiet person captain. Roa – a no show during the Day might be a no show during the Night and thus could do no damage. Ok, I see her point. Valier – getting a bad vibe from Nienna. By the way Rune I know! I was planning on keeping a very close eye out for the start of the game given that it is Nog’s. I think I made my missing Day 1 case well while I was there but I thought I should try even harder than usual not to do it! Aha votes! So: Captain: Boro --> Rune Sally --> Legate Greenie --> Legate Nerwen --> Roa Valier --> Rune Lottie --> Rune Roa --> Legate Rune --> Rune Fea --> Roa Inzil --> Rune Nienna --> Legate Lommy --> Roa Mac --> Kath NG Boro --> Inzil Sally --> Valier Inzil --> Boro Roa --> Brinniel Nerwen --> Kath Lottie --> Boro Rune --> Valier Valier --> Roa Fea --> Nienna Nienna --> Roa Lommy --> Valier Mac --> Brinn Lynch Rune --> Legate Roa --> Rune Nerwen --> Boro Fea --> Hakon Sally --> Rune Nienna --> Rune Lottie --> Nienna Greenie --> Hakon __________________ “If more of us valued food and cheer and song above hoarded gold, it would be a merrier world.”

09-22-2009, 03:53 PM	#3
Kath Everlasting Whiteness Join Date: Jan 2004 Location: Perusing the laminated book of dreams Posts: 4,533	Cross posted since Greenie's vote. Anyway: ++ROA for Captain I think Roa is a good candidate. She is clearly around, engaged and looks to be playing well. I think she's a good first choice. ++ BRINN for Guard It's been too long since I've played with her properly and I don't want to see her gone so early. ++ VALIER I would rather not vote for her because it is her first game in a while but at the moment I don't like the way she is acting. She has just voted for a newbie who hasn't seemed suspicious to me so far and seems to have jumped onto suspicion of Lottie overly quickly. So far as I can work out, she is suspecting Lottie because she is following other people's suspicions rather than coming up with her own. Yet Valier wasn't suspicious of Lottie until Roa brought it up. So it just seems fishy to me. Right, posting this, will check everything is highlighted and/or bolded correctly and will then disappear. __________________ “If more of us valued food and cheer and song above hoarded gold, it would be a merrier world.”

09-22-2009, 03:54 PM	#4
Kath Everlasting Whiteness Join Date: Jan 2004 Location: Perusing the laminated book of dreams Posts: 4,533	Oh and Nog - I just forget when we're actually IN daylight savings time! __________________ “If more of us valued food and cheer and song above hoarded gold, it would be a merrier world.”

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Switch to Linear Mode Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode