Tol-in-Gaurhoth LXIX: Were-Librarians

[alonariel]

Originally Posted by Hakon

I think we can rule out Alona from being a wolf. From the few games I have read through newbies are almost never wolves. One thing all of you need to realize is that if Nienna truly is innocent then she will most likely be killed off real soon. That way we have no one we can say is definitely innocent.

See, in this game, the moddesses pegged the roles at random. The fact that I'm a newbie has nothing to do with the role I received, just as the past history of roles of all the other players have no bearing on the role they received in this game. This makes me not only wary of people who I would generally discern are innocent based on their relationship with the moddesses, but also those who have been wolves in the past. In this case, using your past history against you is essentially useless.

Hakon: You said there's a fair chance I'm not a wolf, but didn't regard me as an innocent. Do you have a hunch about my role like you do Mac's?